ShiloFields

Comments

• I voted no.  Perhaps I am wrong, but my understading is that TR is like Guild Wars, it is not even a MMORPG.  Although it doesn't make a mockery of Star Wars like SWG, purely in terms of featurs TR is worse than SWG even in its current labotomized…

  in Friends, Haters, Veterans Join me in Tabula Rasa. Comment by ShiloFields November 2007
• I am happy for the folks that enjoy SWG. But I am afraid I am going to have to decline your offer.  Its no longer a Star Wars game.

  in Star Wars Galaxies - It's worth playing again try it, I did! Comment by ShiloFields November 2007
• I don't like WoW either.  I may give LOTR another try, but I am afraid pre-CU/NGE SWG has ruined me for other MMOs.  I've done a bunch of free trial and haven't found any that keep my interests. Thanks for the insights.

  in LOTR Review 7 Day Trial Comment by ShiloFields September 2007
• I don't know much about the game I will admit.  People on forums referred to it as a rez so I guess I made the wrong assumption.  Perhaps I rushed to judgment.

  in LOTR Review 7 Day Trial Comment by ShiloFields September 2007
• Originally posted by freakomar Originally posted by ShiloFields I also started the free trial last night.  I wasn't impressed at all.  There is way to much magic which really contradicts the story.  That alone was enough to make my decision eas…

  in LOTR Review 7 Day Trial Comment by ShiloFields September 2007
• I also started the free trial last night.  I wasn't impressed at all.  There is way to much magic which really contradicts the story.  That alone was enough to make my decision easy.  Any developer that won't respect the canon of an IP that is as we…

  in LOTR Review 7 Day Trial Comment by ShiloFields September 2007
• Originally posted by Kyleran Arguements about the game's combat mechanic's aside, the answer to the OP's original question is "no".   Something about Pre-CU SWG "damaged" those who played it.  Maybe it was the way the game was butchered and taken…

  in Can Fallen Earth satisfy the needs of Disgrunted Vets? Comment by ShiloFields September 2007
• Interesting perspecitve.  I always thought Guild Wars was the antithesis of SWG, even more so than WoW.  In SWG you can, or at least could, have a permanent impact on the perisitent world.  In GW, there isn't really a persistent world, or not much o…

  in Guild Wars was like SWG Rehab Comment by ShiloFields August 2007
• Originally posted by sadnebula  but the new game,  say it  just released and it's a  mondo production, would you still be dogging it ? I suppose if you hate Star Wars the current game launched new might be ok.  But even as a new release the g…

  in Is it really swg or Soe Comment by ShiloFields May 2007
• I wouldn't.  Classic servers simply aren't enough.  They have to roll back at least Radiant, to November 14, 2005.  Anything less doesn't fix the problem. 

  in Who Wouldn't Come Back If There were Classic Servers? Comment by ShiloFields April 2007
• PreCu SWG.  No other current MMOs are even in the same league.

  in Your Favorite MMORPG of All Times? Comment by ShiloFields April 2007
• Originally posted by Kyleran Originally posted by ShiloFields Others have said it but it all boils down to: 1.  The game is overly demanding on PC. 2.  Hardcore players think its way too easy.  (original audience) 3.  Casual players think its …

  in What makes this game so bad? Comment by ShiloFields April 2007
• Personally, I think its not complex enough.  Its certainly not hard enough.

  in Is Vanguard Too complex to be fun? Comment by ShiloFields April 2007
• Others have said it but it all boils down to: 1.  The game is overly demanding on PC. 2.  Hardcore players think its way too easy.  (original audience) 3.  Casual players think its too hard.  (audience they want now).

  in What makes this game so bad? Comment by ShiloFields April 2007
• All of the statements regarding customization via items is no different than any other MMO. Vanguard's customization comes via the larger number of classes.  I view that as about equivalent with WoW.  WoW has fewer clases, but there are generally …

  in Character Customization-- why no discussion? Comment by ShiloFields April 2007
• Originally posted by KombatJesus They had to increase the amount of XP per mob. . Remember when the game came out they said that Questin was th ebest way to get XP - this was the vision. . .well. . Sigil screwed over their vision by not providing …

  in Sigil...why? Comment by ShiloFields March 2007
• Originally posted by PyscoJuggalo Same here basically, I could not log on the 27'th At midnight, on the 15'th of November 2005, I drank a bottle of Bacardi 151 and uninstalled SWG.  On the day before I deleted all of my characters except for …

  in When did all of you start playing swg? Comment by ShiloFields March 2007
• I totally agree with the OP.   I figured they would eventually sell out the vision, I just never thought it would be this soon.  Changing your audiences mid stream can be devestating for a MMO (See SWG NGE). Leveling is way to easy as it is.  I ca…

  in Sigil...why? Comment by ShiloFields March 2007
• I think this is more of a each to his own situation. I see all of these are pros.   Not saying you are wrong necessarily.  Just that Vanguard is closer to what I want out of a game than anything on the market.   Originally posted by sepher Con: …

  in Vanguard SOH: Pros and Cons Comment by ShiloFields March 2007
• Originally posted by Areel  If you can find some of the older articles and interviews, it's obvious they entended for the game to be even more hardcore than it is now.  Thanks to the sudden 180 degree turn in the middle of development, they fell b…

  in Ive been looking at Brad's personal webpage. Comment by ShiloFields March 2007
More Comments