Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

CD Projekt Red Has No Intention of to be 'Shy' About Politics - Cyberpunk 2077 - MMORPG.com

2

Comments

  • Lambon23Lambon23 Member UncommonPosts: 66
    soooo if the company doesn't want sexuality and prefers homogeneity, can they be given the same respect??? can we please just give the freedom of expression back to the artists?
  • wowhuntardwowhuntard Member UncommonPosts: 14

    SBFord said:



    Sovrath said:

    Waldoe said:

    SBFord said:
    tomek2626 said:


    so it means we dont get force freiend whit gey or lesbo quests so game be political corect

    Because those things don't happen in real life or aren't part of the world's culture. Gotcha. *facepalms*

    No, it's not that those things are not part of the world culture, or important, at all. However, the number of people that fall into that lifestyle is a very small percentage worldwide yet the number of characters in TV, movies, video games, books etc. is moderately high, at least recently in the mainstream media, and not proportional to the actual number of people that identify that way worldwide.




    So when this concern is brought to light in a fashion unlike this original comment. I think it is worth consideration from that perspective.


    so if a studio, author, developer etc wants to create property with a town filled with Lesbian accountants or a south eastern city solely populated by East Asian bobsled enthusiasts then that's the population of that property and hopefully it works based on what the creators are trying to do.

    But if GLAAD calls on Hollywood to have 20 percent of annual film releases include a gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender or gender fluid character by 2021, rising to 50 percent of output by 2024, it is politics. It is an agenda. It is a form of propaganda.


    GLAAD calling on something doesn't mean it will happen. If it fits the IP contextually and if the people who are making the game or film want their game or film that way, then that is their choice, just as it is the choice of people NOT to purchase a game or film if they disagree with its direction.

    Additionally, why is having characters of all stripes, whatever those stripes are, a bad thing? It was a powerfully emotional day the first time I saw "someone like me" in a game and when I read my first novel that was close to my worldviewview. I don't push an agenda on anyone, but it's an amazing experience for people to be able to identify.

    There's a reason Black Panther resonated so strongly with African Americans and other people of color around the world.



    Suzie, I am blessed to live in one of the most ethnically diverse countries in Europe. I have absolutely no problem with people of all stripes, on the contrary. But I have a problem when someone tries to aggressively influence my opinion (about anything) in a way that resembles overwhelming propaganda campaign and uses all spheres of today's media resources - TV shows, magazines, newspapers, social networks, movies, computer games. My wife's best friend is a lesbian. She is an awesome human being, talented architect, great cook :)... and she fully understands my point of view in this case.

    As for Black Panther, I think that although it resonated so strongly with African Americans, here in Europe people have a little bit different opinion about it, especially having in mind horrors of colonial influence on African continent that is still very apparent and motives of Hollywood money-grabbers and influencers to release such a movie in this moment.

    I apologize for my bad English, not a native speaker here apparently :)
  • TamanousTamanous Member RarePosts: 3,026
    edited July 2018

    Sovrath said:





    Sovrath said:




    Waldoe said:





    SBFord said:







    tomek2626 said:




    so it means we dont get force freiend whit gey or lesbo quests so game be political corect











    Because those things don't happen in real life or aren't part of the world's culture. Gotcha. *facepalms*









    No, it's not that those things are not part of the world culture, or important, at all. However, the number of people that fall into that lifestyle is a very small percentage worldwide yet the number of characters in TV, movies, video games, books etc. is moderately high, at least recently in the mainstream media, and not proportional to the actual number of people that identify that way worldwide.





    So when this concern is brought to light in a fashion unlike this original comment. I think it is worth consideration from that perspective.




    so if a studio, author, developer etc wants to create property with a town filled with Lesbian accountants or a south eastern city solely populated by East Asian bobsled enthusiasts then that's the population of that property and hopefully it works based on what the creators are trying to do.










    But if GLAAD calls on Hollywood to have 20 percent of annual film releases include a gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender or gender fluid character by 2021, rising to 50 percent of output by 2024, it is politics. It is an agenda. It is a form of propaganda.









    And Hollywood, or anyone making movies can do that "or not."

    Just like you can go to those movies "or not."

    If hollywood decided it was "good business" to include as many alternate lifestyles as they can find then that's their "business."

    And that is exactly what it is, a business.

    And they will do what is right for their business. Either purchase their work "or not."

    To me, if the work is good I don't care if it's 100% homosexual or transgender or whatever. If the work is bad then no ratio of any group is going to save it.

    I judge a work on it's success not because it represents "me." Though I do have to have some interest.

    There are plenty of things I don't buy because I'm not interested. And my stance is either buy it or don't. Many people want to see stories that include people like themselves. If it's worth it to the creators/studios, etc then they'll do it. If it's not then they won't.



    But it isn't business. The SWJ agenda injected products are largely losing money, a vast quantity of money ... yet their agenda is still being pushed.

    The heads of the worst infected of the industries and IPs flat out tell their customers that if they don't like it, they can leave. These sort of comments have been quoted over and over again. They attack their fans and through labels at anyone who doesn't agree with them.

    This is not business. This is agenda based politics and a reflection of the times. They are perfectly willing to bleed profits, appropriate and destroy IPs and remove choice in the name of "diversity" (the irony is thick) all in order to protect their influence over what they infiltrated. These are groups running companies for profit that hate the very concept of making profit because they are anti-capitalism. Try wrapping that around your head ... it hurts.

    If losing money on projects was what drove changes in business models then all of this would have died out over 8 years ago. This has nothing to do with business however.

    "Get WOKE ... Go broke"

    I'm not American. I don't give a rats ass about American politics. I just want good entertainment products, and minus a very few, we are seeing a direct decline in true social variety, quality and even straight out appropriation of long standing IPs. I can't ignore this. Lord knows what this article really means about this IP in particular and the true nature of the statement is what worries me. I agree it's always been political in nature but it's NEVER BEEN A CONTEMPORARY, VIRTUE SIGNALLING, IDENTITY AGENDA driven sci-fi but rather a more old school projection of society as a whole.

    I played the RPG with friends for years when younger and I can assure you there was not a class in it called "Gay, Minority, Victim Card Carrying Social Media Crusader". Race, gender, sexual preference and political choices were up to the player and not forced upon them through presentation.

    I hope this game remains true to its origin and that is what the developer means with this statement but recent history across several entertainment fronts proves there is room to worry.
    wowhuntard

    You stay sassy!

  • SephrusSephrus Member UncommonPosts: 76
    I just hope the game has a BOOB slider
  • JeffSpicoliJeffSpicoli Member EpicPosts: 2,849
    Sephrus said:
    I just hope the game has a BOOB slider
    Stop trying to stir the shit pot and post on your real account, not fooling anyone
    Scotinfomatz
    • Aloha Mr Hand ! 

  • UtinniUtinni Member EpicPosts: 2,209
    If you go into a game looking with the attitude of "where the gays at UGH" or "this shit better not point out any flaws in my economic philosphy!" then you will probably find it. Perhaps try playing games for the games, not for how they relate to your own personal beliefs. I'm a pretty wholesome person in real life but it doesn't mean I scoff every time a game gives me the evil option. 
    [Deleted User]MadFrenchieLackingMMOScotSBFordinfomatzThahar
  • LackingMMOLackingMMO Member RarePosts: 664
    Utinni said:
    If you go into a game looking with the attitude of "where the gays at UGH" or "this shit better not point out any flaws in my economic philosphy!" then you will probably find it. Perhaps try playing games for the games, not for how they relate to your own personal beliefs. I'm a pretty wholesome person in real life but it doesn't mean I scoff every time a game gives me the evil option. 
    But on the other note you shouldn't be going in there going "oh this game better have gays!"

    Im so sick of real world politics in games its annoying, this is an rpg, if having something like that in it FITS the story, great! If your trying to put something in it to push your own personal/political agenda, just don't. And that goes for both sides of the view, just stick to good story telling and the rest will fall into place.

    However, in this setting I think people are going to be in for a rude awakening lol. Cyberpunk has always given a the gloves are off, anything goes type of feel to it.
  • ScotScot Member LegendaryPosts: 22,952
    thunderC said:
    Sephrus said:
    I just hope the game has a BOOB slider
    Stop trying to stir the shit pot and post on your real account, not fooling anyone
    I already did a Welcome to the boards for this guy, he is fitting right in. :)
  • cheyanecheyane Member LegendaryPosts: 9,100
    edited July 2018
    I don't think it matters what proportion of  a population a game represents because it is like books and art. It depends on who is making the game. If they want to include a small population of people or minuscule issues that is their choice. Yours is not to buy or play or buy and play.
    Chamber of Chains
  • ScotScot Member LegendaryPosts: 22,952
    KingNaid said:
    MaxBacon said:

    Now on games like Kingdom Come Deliverance where some people got salty as there are only white people, that's just historically accurate.
    https://www.mfa.org/collections/object/tapestry-wild-men-and-moors-106003

    German 1440


    coat of arms of pope benedict xvi



    Welcome to the boards. History for a first post!

    That game was set in Bohemia, I could understand if it was set in what is now Spain, Turkey or  Italy, but Bohemia? Anyway not played it yet still on my wish list. :)
    KingNaid
  • MadFrenchieMadFrenchie Member LegendaryPosts: 8,505
    edited July 2018
    I could see the same argument about population percentages being made 80 years ago, except about <insert minority group that keeps popping up in our games/TV/other media>.
    SovrathArglebargle

    image
  • TheScavengerTheScavenger Member EpicPosts: 3,321
    Being gay/lesbian etc isn't a big deal. I dunno why people in real life make such a big deal out of it, I support it.

    For one, its none of my business what someone else does unless it falls into the line of harming someone (like many people support pedophilia these days and pedophilia jokes, which I am fully against the harm or even joking about the harm of children). But two grown adults? Don't care what they do, as it doesn't effect me in the slightest. Too many people trying to interfere with other peoples lives. Don't care if someone drinks so much its killing themselves, or smokes so much they got cancer or whatever they do with their life, none of my business.

    Second. I actually think gay/lesbian is earth's way of actual population control. Humans are far too many on Earth and keep growing at a far too fast rate...and as seen by many species that were overpopulated on earth, there is always hidden "mechanics" that knock that species population greatly down or slow the population growth. Either through natural disasters, or disease, or in humans cases, gay/lesbian or all kinds of things that nature does to try to curb overpopulation. 

    Third. Gays and lesbians are far more likely to adopt than "straight" people, +1 to that

    Fourth. You got the wackos that say they are going to hell. That means all the romans and people of ancient times are also going to hell. Sounds like the place to go then! Count me in! I don't want to go somewhere where a bunch of prudish and uptight people go that get into everyones business lol. 

    My Skyrim, Fallout 4, Starbound and WoW + other game mods at MODDB: 

    https://www.moddb.com/mods/skyrim-anime-overhaul



  • KingNaidKingNaid Member UncommonPosts: 1,875
    edited July 2018
    Scot said:
    KingNaid said:
    MaxBacon said:

    Now on games like Kingdom Come Deliverance where some people got salty as there are only white people, that's just historically accurate.
    https://www.mfa.org/collections/object/tapestry-wild-men-and-moors-106003

    German 1440


    coat of arms of pope benedict xvi



    Welcome to the boards. History for a first post!

    That game was set in Bohemia, I could understand if it was set in what is now Spain, Turkey or  Italy, but Bohemia? Anyway not played it yet still on my wish list. :)
    Okay
    Related image


    Post edited by KingNaid on
  • XasapisXasapis Member RarePosts: 6,337
    If you liked Skyrim you'll probably enjoy KC:D.
  • SovrathSovrath Member LegendaryPosts: 32,001
    Waldoe said:

    Sovrath said:


    Waldoe said:



    SBFord said:





    tomek2626 said:



    so it means we dont get force freiend whit gey or lesbo quests so game be political corect








    Because those things don't happen in real life or aren't part of the world's culture. Gotcha. *facepalms*






    No, it's not that those things are not part of the world culture, or important, at all. However, the number of people that fall into that lifestyle is a very small percentage worldwide yet the number of characters in TV, movies, video games, books etc. is moderately high, at least recently in the mainstream media, and not proportional to the actual number of people that identify that way worldwide.



    So when this concern is brought to light in a fashion unlike this original comment. I think it is worth consideration from that perspective.


    Except that the stories/settings for characters in TV, movies, Video Games, books, etc aren't real life but snapshots focusing on what the creator wants to say/show.

    No writer writes a book yet doesn't include certain characters because they are a small percentage of the population.

    Whatever the property, the characters included are meant to be there and are meant to support the "world building" of that property.

    They are pieces of whatever creation the creator wants to create. They aren't supposed to represent an exact copy of our real world.

    edit: so if a studio, author, developer etc wants to create property with a town filled with Lesbian accountants or a south eastern city solely populated by East Asian bobsled enthusiasts then that's the population of that property and hopefully it works based on what the creators are trying to do.







    SBFord was making the point that LGBT community should have a place in games because they are part of real life throughout the world, which is absolutely true. So I made the point that the representation of the approximate percent of people in the world that identify with a particular lifestyle is not proportionally represented in a lot of the mainstream entertainment these days which is why I addressed the comment in the same terms.

    Sovrath, if you want to change the perspective we are looking at this from that is fine. I agree with what you are saying. However, one would be naive to think there is not pressure (whether it is from the money source or fear of backlash or something else) to include certain types of characters. Creators have freedom but unless they are self-funding something, others are going to have a say in what ultimately makes the page or screen etc.
    I agree there is "pressure" to include people with different lifestyles but that doesn't mean that it will happen. And I also agree that "others will have a say."

    That's why I added that it's a business and if a studio/publiser, etc thinks it's good business they'll add more characters with different lifestyles, races, etc.

    And if they don't then they won't. I still think it's refreshing to see different people, different lifestyles on screen as it adds more realism and diversity to movies. Same with games. It feels more real.

    Then again, I live in a city with people from many walks of life (not saying they all get together in perfect harmony!) and it's not unusual to see greater diversity in various parts of the city.


    SBFord
    Like Skyrim? Need more content? Try my Skyrim mod "Godfred's Tomb." 

    Godfred's Tomb Trailer: https://youtu.be/-nsXGddj_4w


    Original Skyrim: https://www.nexusmods.com/skyrim/mods/109547

    Try the "Special Edition." 'Cause it's "Special." https://www.nexusmods.com/skyrimspecialedition/mods/64878/?tab=description

    Serph toze kindly has started a walk-through. https://youtu.be/UIelCK-lldo 
  • XasapisXasapis Member RarePosts: 6,337
    People don't want to play ordinary (usually).

    And ordinary people are not usually interesting, unless the authors/directors put them into extraordinary situations.

    Generally speaking however, the most interesting characters are the flawed ones.

    Specific to Cyberpunk, it'll be interesting to explore a situation that all of us will not experience, the loss of humanity while turning more and more into a machine.
    SBFord
  • CIB3CIB3 Member UncommonPosts: 121
    edited July 2018
    For me it's easy, I don't buy, watch or support anything with "gay". Because it's disgusting for me. If I go to cinema and the movie have LGBT characters depicted in a positive way in it I go out and ask for a refund. I don't pay for their agenda.
    [Deleted User]infomatz
  • SovrathSovrath Member LegendaryPosts: 32,001
    edited July 2018
    Tamanous said:



    But it isn't business.
    To Clarify: if a business thinks that "it's a good thing" whether it makes money or not then they will do it. Part of being "good business" is also PR.

    And you'd have to prove to me that anything and everything with people of other lifestyles loses money because it offers glimpses of alternate lifestyles

    Rent did very well, Hedwig did very well, Will & Grace did very well.

    Moonlight did very well given it's budget. Made it's money back many times over.

    If a property is good it will do well. Might not be for everyone but that's ok.

    more: La cage aux folles, The Bird Cage, Milk.

    Edit: as far as "pushing an agenda", people want to see themselves represented and I think that's very fair.

    If they want to continue to clamor for more representation then more power to them. If people don't want to see content with more representation then you don't have to. It doesn't matter if 50 movies come out representing people with other lifestyles, it doesn't take anything away from you as there will be 50 movies that don't represent people with other lifestyles.


    MadFrenchie
    Like Skyrim? Need more content? Try my Skyrim mod "Godfred's Tomb." 

    Godfred's Tomb Trailer: https://youtu.be/-nsXGddj_4w


    Original Skyrim: https://www.nexusmods.com/skyrim/mods/109547

    Try the "Special Edition." 'Cause it's "Special." https://www.nexusmods.com/skyrimspecialedition/mods/64878/?tab=description

    Serph toze kindly has started a walk-through. https://youtu.be/UIelCK-lldo 
  • blamo2000blamo2000 Member RarePosts: 1,130
    On steam there is an early access game called Almost Alive. It has a lot of perks and traits. The one called capitalist makes you stupider by taking it. The one called communist makes you smarter by taking it. He is selling this on steam, to get enough money to make the game. The irony would be amazing if it wasn't so common.

    There is only one political narrative that games can embrace and espouse - and the people defending it agree with the narrative. Its no different than Hollywood. No one in entertainment has the courage to try and be objective and rational. Why? Because one side will literally destroy you for the attempt. Look at what happened recently with Mark Duplass.

    I am a colored person that is a reformed Democrat and now belong to neither side of the ideological debate. I just know I play games to relax and recharge my batteries - not be indoctrinated with nonsense from small minded sycophants. I like fantasy and sci-fi settings to escape from this world, not have the hot button political issues repackaged and regurgitated to me in a different setting from the same hive-mind of hyper-partisan ideologues.

    But, for full disclosure I should admit I like my games to be great games and not try and be slightly interactive movies so I am not the target market of CD Project Red or other devs that try and mark art instead of games, or tell stories instead of making rpgs.
  • xmentyxmenty Member UncommonPosts: 718
    edited July 2018
    I was wondering whether they will go to extreme like consentual incest or pedophilia ( eg. father and son or mother and daughter ) cos everytime you asked the pro gays/lesb or the gay/lesb themselves, they would say as long it does not hurt anyone, it should be ok. I saw this on youtube and made me think. search it on youtube if you want to see their discussion on it. "The Lowest Moral Standards - Mansur Ahmad vs Atheist"

    Pardon my English as it is not my 1st language :)

  • ScotScot Member LegendaryPosts: 22,952
    Xasapis said:
    People don't want to play ordinary (usually).

    And ordinary people are not usually interesting, unless the authors/directors put them into extraordinary situations.

    Generally speaking however, the most interesting characters are the flawed ones.

    Specific to Cyberpunk, it'll be interesting to explore a situation that all of us will not experience, the loss of humanity while turning more and more into a machine.
    You mean using word processers rather than writing? Talking to people on mobiles rather than face to face? Using fitness tracker watches to monitor our performance? Talking, socialising, shopping and living online rather than in the real world?

    Our technology and tools have changed who we are since the flint was invented, every stride forward has made us lose something. Cyberware as suggested by cyberpunk could take that to unforeseeable levels, but I look at amputees with these amazing prosthetics they now have and wonder if the fears of that genre are somewhat groundless? We will lose something, but it will not be as truly pivotal, it does make a grand device for drama though.
  • ScotScot Member LegendaryPosts: 22,952
    edited August 2018
    Scot said:
    Xasapis said:
    People don't want to play ordinary (usually).

    And ordinary people are not usually interesting, unless the authors/directors put them into extraordinary situations.

    Generally speaking however, the most interesting characters are the flawed ones.

    Specific to Cyberpunk, it'll be interesting to explore a situation that all of us will not experience, the loss of humanity while turning more and more into a machine.
    You mean using word processers rather than writing? Talking to people on mobiles rather than face to face? Using fitness tracker watches to monitor our performance? Talking, socialising, shopping and living online rather than in the real world?

    Our technology and tools have changed who we are since the flint was invented, every stride forward has made us lose something. Cyberware as suggested by cyberpunk could take that to unforeseeable levels, but I look at amputees with these amazing prosthetics they now have and wonder if the fears of that genre are somewhat groundless? We will lose something, but it will not be as truly pivotal, it does make a grand device for drama though.
    Most of your example is simply sophisticated tool usage. The idea with cybertech in the Cyberpunk 2020 source material is about becoming more machine than human. Its not just about the technology but also the philosophy of what makes us human. It touches on the concept of life force, the soul, chi, chakra, whatever you want to call it. The more machine you become the less human you are. There's also a nasty little thing called cyberpsychosis where too many implants and changes can drive a person stark raving mad. I've always looked upon it like a sanity check in the H.P. Lovecraft games.

    Whether the fear of such things is groundless, I have to disagree. Someone becoming superhuman from cybernetic implants could easily start to see the unaugmented as inferior. And considering the widespread murder and atrocities committed last century over just the idea of superiority, how much worse could that ideology become if through technology people really did start to become more human than human?
    I am quite conversant with the genre, but it did seem to me that according to the genre just replacing body parts was sufficient to cause the psychosis you mention. That's a stretch when we see how people cope with prothesis, not saying they don't have psychological issues, just becoming something other than human is not one of them to my knowledge. As you say there was a metaphysical side to the genre, which I am happy to leave to the theologians, who can say whether our "souls" would be effected? But correct if I am wrong, was that not more in the RPG than the books?

    Also you are right, my examples were sophisticated tool usage, but look at how that tool usage has changed our behaviour, which is to such a great extent what we are.

    People with superior machine bodies may think they have some sort of superiority over "normals". Once again I look to the real world, I see Olympic athletes who could certainly see themselves as superior to most of us physically and that this is not causing issues like widespread murder. So again I think it is a great vehicle for drama but not something for us to really worry about.

    Where I do agree that cyperpunk highlighted the real dangers of cyberware was the way  cyberware could effect our brains. With technology from skill chips to jacking into virtual worlds ((for our millennial readers there was no wi-fi in the 90's :) )), that is why I talked of us potential losing "unforeseeable levels" of what it means to be human.

    Have to say the quality of discourse on MMORPG.com only gets better, I usually have conversations like this on science forums!
  • ArglebargleArglebargle Member EpicPosts: 3,395
    edited August 2018
    Cyberpsychosis is just a game schtick/abstraction to frame the ideas, and provide a break against just adding everything.  It's a gamism.  Not to my taste as a design element, but its a consistent element of the backstory and PnP RPG.

    Certainly we haven't got enough of it yet in RL to delineate this.  But good SF is about projection of present day changes into their extremes, and how it changes things.

    https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/CyberneticsEatYourSoul
    Scot

    If you are holding out for the perfect game, the only game you play will be the waiting one.

  • cheyanecheyane Member LegendaryPosts: 9,100
    Yeah Lando always struck  as ambiguous, 'pan' I guess.
    Gorwe
    Chamber of Chains
  • GutlardGutlard Member RarePosts: 1,019
    Prejudices & biases are just mental handicaps. Some are more mentally handicapped than others. Hate is easy and lazy, love can take a lot of work but is the most fulfilling. I hope those who are full of hate, at least find love in others that are also full of hate, and maybe they'll find some happiness in their empty lives.

    I'm tired of all the whining from all sides. I'm tired of all the finger pointing from all sides. I'm tired of all the outside world bullshit pushing in on my happy gaming place. Make any story interesting and I'll want to play it. Make the gameplay fun and I'll be entertained.

    Hurt any kid in front of me and I'll do anything in my 6'2" 290lb power to make you regret your life decisions, mmmkay buttercup?

    Gut Out!

    What, me worry?

Sign In or Register to comment.