It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Personally I have a problem with the Guild Wars desktop icon's quality. I don't feel it looks sharp enough; it's rather blurry and has very little detail to it. Now some people are going to most likely sit back and read this, and say "Who the @#$! cares?". I have a habit of perfection in particular areas, you might say a little OCD, and I just think that their team should put a little more work into it.
The World of Warcraft icon is quality work though.
FYI: This topic is not a "World of Warcraft pwns Guild Wars" topic; I love both games