Howdy, Stranger!
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Quick Links
Why not relaunch SWG pre-cu?
This discussion has been closed.
It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Comments
One of the most popular games today is Minecraft, if that's acceptable by today's standards pretty much anything is.
For every minute you are angry , you lose 60 seconds of happiness."-Emerson
While i could spend the rest of the day lecturing of the difference between a stylistic choice and degraded quality i do not feel i need to do that. The OP asked if i had some reasons for why it would not be relaunched... That was one.. but as you see it was also fairly low on the list and one can do a lot with a "simple" texture update.
Then again i think Minecraft look like utter dung too and it is the main reason i do not play it and why i look towards Landmark instead.
That is a lot of work for something that will earn them no revenue and barley any goodwill.
This have been a good conversation
Unfortunately there are plenty of reasons not to simply "try it and see". What you're talking about is basically just tossing it out there without any support, which sounds nice, but there always needs to be someone on maintenance, some sort of hardware, someone to push the button and cycle servers, someone to handle your complaints, and so on and so forth. Problem is, re-launching it like this would basically be suiciding it because you don't have appropriate staff to help new people, potential customers, etc. If you were to re-launch it, you'd need to do it right. Trust me, if you got 100K sigs on a petition they could extrapolate that and figure out their potential market. You'd start to open some eyes.
As per the highlighted part, to make the assumption that, based on your years of gaming experience, if you like it, everyone will, you don't really help your argument.
Crazkanuk
----------------
Azarelos - 90 Hunter - Emerald
Durnzig - 90 Paladin - Emerald
Demonicron - 90 Death Knight - Emerald Dream - US
Tankinpain - 90 Monk - Azjol-Nerub - US
Brindell - 90 Warrior - Emerald Dream - US
----------------
A reminder about the rules of this forum:
To give feedback on moderation, contact [email protected]
I find it funny how many people say "cause no one played it back then, so why would they now". I assume the people who say that never played the game? They also probably where to young or just not into MMORPG's. Cause here is the thing. We are talking about SWG Pre sony screw up. Back then for its time it was a popular MMORPG. Unlike today back then a lot less people played games. In those years gaming was concidered something for nerds only. The MMORPG genre was even less populated , not until WoW the MMORPG genre became booming and next FPS the leading genre on pc gaming.
People have such a hard time to understand that. Back then a couple of thousand players was a lot. It was a niche genre and SWG had a great community until they changed the game. Over one night they lost most of their community. Maybe these days those numbers are nothing, but back then it was a huge blow. After that the game never recovered from the blow. But that one isn't the version people talk about when they say they want SWG back. They want the times back the Jedi wasn't a class you could pick from the start but had to work your ass off to become one.
And how arrogant is it of people to say "the game is dead, no one played it, get over it those times are over". Is it really that weird that people who played the MMORPG genre before you did want their experience back they had back then? When a MMORPG was a world presented to you and do your thing in it, rather then holding your hand and telling you what to do and when to do it. I would love to see a remake of SWG with today's graphics and a better combat system as it is possible these days, back then they where limited. Yeah smart guys, back then the combat system was also limited cause of slower internet.
But really people, it where different times. A few thousand players back then where a massive crowd.
I could be wrong but i heard that the emulator is perfectly legal. Not to defend it and i won't name any names of the emulator, but a well known youtuber is having a series about that emulator and SONY nor Disney have seemed to step in either to stop the emulator, sounds pretty legal to me. And it is the old abandoned version on SWG, as long as you own the game legally it is legal to join that emulator.
If im wrong then im sorry and feel free to remove my post.
How long would people play it stuck in time with no updates?
IF they did update it and people disagreed with the changes would they stamp their feet and leave like they did last time?
TSW - AoC - Aion - WOW - EVE - Fallen Earth - Co - Rift - || XNA C# Java Development
Boobs are LIFE, Boobs are LOVE, Boobs are JUSTICE, Boobs are mankind's HOPES and DREAMS. People who complain about boobs have lost their humanity.
I thought a bunch of fans were rebuilding and running a pre cu version of this game if you miss it so much you can still play it from what I understand all you need is the original discs
Actually, MMORPG populations back then were generally bigger than the ones today. EQ, FFXI, SWG, DAoC, and UO were all over 200k subs. the last MMORPG to have over 200k subs after even its first year was LOTRO. Maybe FFXIV has that actually. SWG's 250k would be a big success in today's environment, but back then it wasnt a big deal at all. And was definitely a population going in the wrong direction in an era were multi year growth was the norm and expectation.
Obviously WoW changed people's perception of what a population could be, but WoW remains an anomaly. Had LucasArts and SoE been able to see into the future (not of NGE, but of the industry) perhaps they would have done things differently.
You are not wrong, they have permission to do what they are doing until Disney decides to pull the plug, if they ever do. I am not sure why this site refuses to allow it to be discussed even though this is now well known information.
Are you allowed to talk about them in general? As in, not mention any one specific server? Would it be against the rules if I said "hey, a lot of people still play on various private UO shards." ?
It's nice of you to make excuses for a game that by SOE own acknowledgment was not successful. So smart guy please explain this...
Subscriber numbers were originally expected to exceed 1,000,000.[59] In early 2006, unconfirmed reports showed that only 10,363 subscribers were playing on a particular Friday night, but Smedley denied that subscriptions had fallen this low.
They never ever came close to their expected numbers.
Note Smed never denied only 10k were playing on a prime Friday night, and did not say how far subs actually did fall. So as far back as '06 it's clear nobody was playing and the game was in maintenance mode for years until it closed. So yes smart guy nobody played it back then nobody would play it now.
Because if that was true, there would be no need to ask why the game isn't being relaunched...
Its in a grey area. Disney absolutely could shut it down if they felt like it. SoE will never shut it down as long as Smedley is in charge. its not taking away from either company financially and no profit is being made.
There is an emu server for a different game that *is* directly taking customers from SoE but they let that one go too. Say what you want about Smedley, but anyone playing on one of those nameless servers should appreciate that Smedley is willing to look the other way for them.
The reason why the site doesnt like discussion is these servers are the exceptions rather than the norm. most emu servers are illegal. easier to blanket it for all servers than allowing one or two here and there.
The game is over 10 years old, the code was extremely buggy and re-launching it with old graphics and no fixes would just flop even if Disney didn't own the rights. The game was fairly low budget with a $8M budget, something today would be considered bad for an indie game.
What should be done is taking all the good ideas from the game and make a new game with modern graphics and a better engine. The game really did have plenty of good ideas after all.
I agree with alot you say, the game was very buggy and if they would make a new SWG with the same formula and adding some stuff then it would be a hit but in all fairness I played SWG and I would never go back to that game. There were good stuff in it but to many problems to.
There is a reason it closed down, it didn't have a large enough playerbase and with the new Star Wars game on the horizon it was for them a good buisness move.
I googled SWG private servers and I found one but there was like 23 people online and there record was something like 300 online at the same time but if all you vets want to join just google it and you can still play your favorite game
All of that is true.
And yet, SWG did things 10 years ago that the developers of today say is "too hard":
Non-instanced player housing
Variable stat crafting and resource system
32+ prof dynamic skill system
Player run shops and vendors that tied into to a global market system
Multi-player ships on the Space game side
And that is just a few things off the top of my head, and things that people have asked for since then and other developers couldn't deliver, basically any of them.
What the game needed more than anything else was 6 month before launch to finish things up and stomp bugs. Launching early was one of SOE biggest mistakes with this game, only to be exceeded by the CU and NGE game revisions.
Pre CU sucked. Post CU pre NGE is where it needs to be.
Im not going back to any game remotely close to pre CU SWG. EVER.
^
That era was good for TKs.
I must say that was pretty much my favorite era as well; a lot of things were broken then, though (ie splicing, etc).
http://wyrdblogging.blogspot.com/