It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
Originally posted by Aeonblades I found that out my first day here. Never criticize GW2 on this site for sure, it's like asking for butthurt people to report you. Age of Paytowinshu is another. Fans can be rabid anywhere, it's not just MMORPG.com, it just happens more often here because I think the warnings are issued without an actual human looking at the complaint.
I call bs.
You can criticize any game on this site. What you can't do is to say "aw man X sucks, it's total garbage, looks like sh*t; what the heck do these idiot developers think they are doing.
Originally posted by cronius77 Originally posted by BadSpock Constructive criticism or negative opinions presented in a way that is objectively positive is really, really hard to do.
they DO NOT allow you to post neagtives on a game even using constructive criticism . Ive been banned many times for that and their only excuse was postig excess negative comments about a game... It happens the most on guild wars 2 and ive NEVER even been that critical by trashing the game and have always backed up my posts with reasons for why i do not like it compared to other games or personal opinion. I try not to be rude in my posts but have had bans for personal attacks when I didnt even attack anyone or just defended myself as well.
Their policy is pretty much say your peace and move on. Fair or not that's the policy. If you're consistently hanging around a forum for a game you don't like, bringing up your reasons for not liking it in every thread, they will eventually warn or temp ban you. I've never quite undertsood why people do that anyway.
For every minute you are angry , you lose 60 seconds of happiness."-Emerson
If all you can ever offer is a sarcastic LOL, you are most likely better off not offering an argument for the world to read, it reeks of immaturity.
Originally posted by RefMinor Originally posted by botrytis Originally posted by RefMinor Originally posted by botrytis Originally posted by RefMinor Originally posted by BadSpock Constructive criticism or negative opinions presented in a way that is objectively positive is really, really hard to do.
Great stupid post.
Not stupid - one actually has to think to be constructive. BadSpock is spot on with his assessment. One really has to sit down and think about a respose or reply. Since this is the instant gratification society, one just pushes the bottun and doesn't care. Knee jerk reaction time.
Sense of humour not your strong suit?
If you actually would post a joke - I might laugh....
"In 50 years, when I talk to my grandchildren about these days, I'll make sure to mention what an accomplished MMO player I was. They are going to be so proud ..."by Naqaj - 7/17/2013 MMORPG.com forum
I hope we shall crush...in its birth the aristocracy of our moneyed corporations, which dare already to challenge our government to a trial of strength and bid defiance to the laws of our country." ~Thomes Jefferson
Originally posted by jtcgs The best part of this site is that someone can reply with a blatant troll WITH a direct attack and his post will sit there, but if you reply that he is a troll...the ban hammer hits you, your post is deleted...while the troll and attack sits there.
in my experience direct attacks are removed pretty fast overall
I angered the clerk in a clothing shop today. She asked me what size I was and I said actual, because I am not to scale. I like vending machines 'cause snacks are better when they fall. If I buy a candy bar at a store, oftentimes, I will drop it... so that it achieves its maximum flavor potential. --Mitch Hedberg
Negative posts require supporting arguments and a lack of "attack words" I like to call them.
Most people who post negative opinions don't do that.
What are attack words?
Things like "dumbed down" and "casuals" and "console generation" and other such phrases that are very thinly veiled insults towards other gamers/posters.
There is a BIG difference on this website to these moderators between saying -
"I thought that the control scheme and choice of on-demand available skills was both lacking and overly simplistic, any attempt at depth merely felt like tedius button mashing versus true tactical control."
"The devs dumbed down the controls and ability bars for the console generation, the sequel will probably one have one button you mash your thumbs against repeatedly to dispense loot."
The original post being a troll is only your opinion, the Mods obviously disagree, but your direct attack is a direct attack. Therefore you get the ban and the post remains.
That's a common policy, across every mainstream forum I've known, from games to hardware junkies to electronics. You're supposed to report the suspected "troll", instead of responding ... which reduces the thread to gooey slop. When someone responds to a troll, someone else will respond, then another, and everything gets unmanageable shortly thereafter. Then come the insults. Next thing anyone knows they are talking about the transition of Barbie outfits between the 70's and 90's.
Want a nice understanding of life? Try Spirit Science: "The Human History"http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U8NNHmV3QPw&feature=plcpRecognize the voice? Yep sounds like Penny Arcade's Extra Credits.
Originally posted by essaidi Seriously never been a member of such a community I can't say a game looks ugly without getting a warning from you guys, its your site and your decission, but makes a lot of sense to me now why so few even uses your forums when you can't act like anything but a fanboy, or you will get warnings, I'll probably get a warning for this one as well.. But to be serious I don't care... If I think a game has a graphic that looks like it was made in 1950 I'm going to say it....
You'll find the sight rife with employees ( with multiple accounts ) of the site that stir and move conversation to maintain traffic. After all site like this charge advertising based on traffic , so it's in their interest .
You'll also find that employees or agents of the companies themselves posting surreptitiously, promoting their products or dismissing/panning the competitors products. It's all part of the game.
There are ordinary people here also with opinions and points of view, some like to post others view it as a sport on how to aggravate and inflame others only to report them. You'll find that the site tends to favor posters from the companies that pay to advertise here. Part of how the world works. Unfortunately there are no rules for full disclosure for the companies that run these sites and posters. Enjoy the banter , participate at your own risk , critic if you dare and who you dare , but be prepared for a time out if you critic too harshly the wrong person.
Originally posted by MightyChasm It was a joke bub. But I think you illistrated one part of the problem on these forums, people take everything far too seriously.
Ah, see It's hard to tell here when someone is joking or not, thanks for clarification!
Currently Playing: ESO and FFXIVHave played: You name itIf you mention rose tinted glasses, you better be referring to Mitch Hedberg.
So what did computer graphics look like in the 1950s? I didn't start coding until 1977, and they were pretty bad back then. Lots of text on a teletype mostly. Video terminal if you were high tech.
Ken Fisher - Semi retired old fart Network Administrator, now working in Network Security. I don't Forum PVP. If you feel I've attacked you, it was probably by accident. When I don't understand, I ask. Such is not intended as criticism.
You know the really sad part is that once upon a time mmorpg.com was a highly respected review site.
Now its just a joke wrapped in denial and deception.
Originally posted by RefMinor Originally posted by jtcgs The best part of this site is that someone can reply with a blatant troll WITH a direct attack and his post will sit there, but if you reply that he is a troll...the ban hammer hits you, your post is deleted...while the troll and attack sits there.
Actually, when a thread is going on track and 2-3 people are responding in kind debating a topic and someone replies to a long post WITH bulletpoints on his refutes with "stop complaining like a little girl and go play WoW"...there is little doubt about the troll attempt...and replying with "we are having a discussion here can you please troll someplace else" really shouldnt be a bannable offense. But that is the occasional derp level of the site depending on who has their finger over the ban button that day.
Originally posted by XAPGames So what did computer graphics look like in the 1950s? I didn't start coding until 1977, and they were pretty bad back then. Lots of text on a teletype mostly. Video terminal if you were high tech.
Originally posted by AG-Vuk Originally posted by essaidi Seriously never been a member of such a community I can't say a game looks ugly without getting a warning from you guys, its your site and your decission, but makes a lot of sense to me now why so few even uses your forums when you can't act like anything but a fanboy, or you will get warnings, I'll probably get a warning for this one as well.. But to be serious I don't care... If I think a game has a graphic that looks like it was made in 1950 I'm going to say it....
The term is Astroturfing. It's been loosely in and out of the news.
published: 2012-03-27 21:15:06
It was such a problem in industries promoting a product, from electronics to beauty creams, that Astroturfing was made illegal (fairly recently the FTC guidelines were modified to include forum/blog advertising with false pretext & not identifying their relation to the endorsing company): Astroturfing violates the FTC Endorsement and Advertising Guidelines, under section 255.5 (http://ecfr.gpoaccess.gov/cgi/t/text/text-idx?c=ecfr&rgn=div8&view=text&node=16:126.96.36.199.188.8.131.52&idno=16).
Furthering that, a smear campaign got Facebook in some big doodoo a couple years ago. I guess astroturfers nowadays are careful to reveal differences between products and not specifically smear a competitors product or its designers (ie: that game sucks, developers for that "other" game are retards, etc), or instigate arguments & downplay another game outside of a comparison context (under the guise of educational discussion).
So does it still happen on 3rd party websites / forums? Probably, though not legally. Can companies like Blizzard and EA astroturf their own official forums? Can any company? Their own forums - yes. 3rd party forums - NO.
That said, it's also highly unethical to spam forums with how great a game is, without telling everyone first that you also are affiliated with the manufacturer and / or the product.
Some companies participate in this practice, but not legally (in the USA - I'm not sure how Europe adopted these laws).
Originally posted by Karteli Originally posted by AG-Vuk Originally posted by essaidi Seriously ..... it....
You'll ..... person.
To that, I'll just add that US laws only apply directly to people living in the US , and US companies and Subsidaries in the US. That being said the entire purpose of corporate lawyers is to find ways around the rules to benefit the client. The old saying, where there is a will, there is a way.
one thing i have noticed is some posters use the "with all due respect" approach to some forums.. seems some feel if they say a couple nice comments towards a game it gives them carte blanche to bash the game in every thread.. but again i don't really see an issue with posting constructive critisism on any game as if people didn't these forums would be a pretty boring place with not much discussion at all... everything would be
BOB: Game x is the BEST
JIM: i AGREE best ever!