It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
I've had posts like this before, and they seemed to get people to update thier review ratings of games, so I guess I'll have to do it again. Right now Guild Wars 2 is number one rating (by alot) and The Secret World is second (also by alot).
Now I haven't played Guild Wars 2 and only a month of The Secret World, so this isn't a thread about how good or bad they are, however, I know alot of friends that left WoW and Rift to go play them, and I noticed recently that almost everyone is back. Looking through my friendslist in these games, I've noticed in WoW only 2 people missing (my friendlist is full btw). In Rift, my friendlist is only missing about 10 people (which is also full). After the launch of Guild Wars 2, about half my guild left to go play it, and even more % of my friendlist went to go play it. After talking to them, they were all dissapointed with it. They said it's no Guild Wars 1, and even though it's free after you buy the game, they aren't going back anytime soon.
This leads me to believe that the ratings (as any poll really) are skewed and/or people haven't updated thier ratings since launch. I personally never trust ratings anyways. My favorite game of all time, Zelda 64: Ocarina of time, got mixed reviews, which I don't see how. To me there isn't a single game that comes even close to it...Heck I still play the 3DS version to this day.
So please update your ratings regularly, thanks From what I've heard people talking about, Planetside 2 should be first anyways...Other than it being an SOE game, I won't touch, It sounds like the greatest game ever. Barely seen or heard anything bad about it.