Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Could a game with SWG's Mechanics, but not the SW IP be successful?

TheLizardbonesTheLizardbones Arkham, VAMember Posts: 10,910 Common

Title pretty much asks the question. Would game written using the best of SWG's mechanics be successful, without actually being based in the Star Wars Universe? What if the game was a straight up Fantasy Western, instead of a Space Western? What if it was a straight up Medieval Fantasy game? How much did the IP contribute to peoples' fond memories of SWG?

I can not remember winning or losing a single debate on the internet.

Comments

  • Paradigm68Paradigm68 New York, NYMember Posts: 890 Uncommon
    I think it would be huge.  I've been thinking this a long time. Take SWG, upgrade the graphics and replace the IP with an original but fairly generic sci-fi IP and you've got a hit. Get rid of the alpha class, the people who're coming in with preconcieved expectatons and it'd be pretty sweet.
  • niceguy3978niceguy3978 Gainesville, FLMember Posts: 1,969 Uncommon
    Originally posted by lizardbones
    Title pretty much asks the question. Would game written using the best of SWG's mechanics be successful, without actually being based in the Star Wars Universe? What if the game was a straight up Fantasy Western, instead of a Space Western? What if it was a straight up Medieval Fantasy game? How much did the IP contribute to peoples' fond memories of SWG?

    A game with one of if not the biggest IP in the history of IP's could never crack 300k.  If it didn't have star wars attatched to it, I doubt it would have had 1/3 of those players.

    Edit:  The game launched in April of 2003, and on August 25, 2005 Sony announced they had sold 1 million boxes.  So it took them almost 2 1/2 years to even sell a million units of the game.

  • OnomasOnomas USAMember Posts: 1,129 Uncommon
    Originally posted by niceguy3978
    Originally posted by lizardbones
    Title pretty much asks the question. Would game written using the best of SWG's mechanics be successful, without actually being based in the Star Wars Universe? What if the game was a straight up Fantasy Western, instead of a Space Western? What if it was a straight up Medieval Fantasy game? How much did the IP contribute to peoples' fond memories of SWG?

    A game with one of if not the biggest IP in the history of IP's could never crack 300k.  If it didn't have star wars attatched to it, I doubt it would have had 1/3 of those players.

    Edit:  The game launched in April of 2003, and on August 25, 2005 Sony announced they had sold 1 million boxes.  So it took them almost 2 1/2 years to even sell a million units of the game.

    Thats like comparing a 2013 ferrari to a model t.

     

    You can not compare 2003 to todays market. In 2003 only 35-40% of people had internet to begin with. 2nd MMO's were designed for adults, not kids. 3rd 300k in 2003 was a huge number.

    Then the release of WOW brought a lot more people into the mmo fold, but they targeted the younger crowd. Thats what steam rolled MMO's into the dumbed down mmo's they are today.

    Many people have been screaming for a new sandbox like SWG, and it would be huge. It would give many here a new awspect/look at mmo's. For many people they havent tried nor had the pleasure of enjoying a true mmo with all its features.

     

  • TraugarTraugar Robbinsville, NCMember Posts: 183 Uncommon
    Originally posted by lizardbones
    Title pretty much asks the question. Would game written using the best of SWG's mechanics be successful, without actually being based in the Star Wars Universe? What if the game was a straight up Fantasy Western, instead of a Space Western? What if it was a straight up Medieval Fantasy game? How much did the IP contribute to peoples' fond memories of SWG?

    I wish it would happen.  Star Wars is my favorite IP, but I have so many preconcieved notions on how to do SW correctly that it is almost impossible for a game to meet my expectations.  Don't misunderstand me.  I love playing SW games, but I would prefer a swg like game to not be SW simply because so many peoples ideas of what is Star Wars differ from one another.  

  • niceguy3978niceguy3978 Gainesville, FLMember Posts: 1,969 Uncommon
    Originally posted by Onomas
    Originally posted by niceguy3978
    Originally posted by lizardbones
    Title pretty much asks the question. Would game written using the best of SWG's mechanics be successful, without actually being based in the Star Wars Universe? What if the game was a straight up Fantasy Western, instead of a Space Western? What if it was a straight up Medieval Fantasy game? How much did the IP contribute to peoples' fond memories of SWG?

    A game with one of if not the biggest IP in the history of IP's could never crack 300k.  If it didn't have star wars attatched to it, I doubt it would have had 1/3 of those players.

    Edit:  The game launched in April of 2003, and on August 25, 2005 Sony announced they had sold 1 million boxes.  So it took them almost 2 1/2 years to even sell a million units of the game.

    Thats like comparing a 2013 ferrari to a model t.

     

    You can not compare 2003 to todays market. In 2003 only 35-40% of people had internet to begin with. 2nd MMO's were designed for adults, not kids. 3rd 300k in 2003 was a huge number.

    Then the release of WOW brought a lot more people into the mmo fold, but they targeted the younger crowd. Thats what steam rolled MMO's into the dumbed down mmo's they are today.

    Many people have been screaming for a new sandbox like SWG, and it would be huge. It would give many here a new awspect/look at mmo's. For many people they havent tried nor had the pleasure of enjoying a true mmo with all its features.

     

    It launched in a time when two very successfull mmos had been created, actually 3.  Sony themselves expected a million subs.  But they couldn't even match an unknown IP's popularity.

  • QuizzicalQuizzical Member Posts: 16,746 Epic

    If the reason people fondly remember SWG were the IP rather than the game mechanics, don't you think they'd be content playing SWTOR rather than wanting SWG back?

    If a game did match SWG game mechanics but not the IP, I think a lot of supposedly SWG fans would try it out, declare that it wasn't as good as SWG, and quit.  You can't compete with nostalgia.  A lot of them also would play it and be happy for a while, of course.

  • strangiato2112strangiato2112 Richmond, VAMember Posts: 1,538 Common

    whats forgotten about is that Lucas Arts pushed SWG out the door 6-12 months too early.  The PvE 'content' was putrid at launch, and the balance was probably the worst in MMORPG history.  SWG was a complete disaster in many, many aspects.

    Except the social and crafting ones.  

     

    I think if EQNext were to borrow heavily from SWG it would be a hit.  Maybe not a smash hit, but could top 500k.

  • strangiato2112strangiato2112 Richmond, VAMember Posts: 1,538 Common
    Originally posted by Onomas Then the release of WOW brought a lot more people into the mmo fold, but they targeted the younger crowd.   

    WoW did appeal to an early-mid 20s player more than a game like EQ did, but WoW merely set out to make a MMORPG based on Warcraft IP.  the appeal to a somewhat younger crowd was a side affect of it being a blizzard game and having more sway with PC gamers.

  • ThorkuneThorkune Eastern, KYMember Posts: 1,931 Uncommon

    I feel that it would be a huge hit. I have been trying to fill the SWG void since it shut down. But, there will never be a replacement for it in my mind.

    I was thinking about SWG's tatooine sand storms earlier today. SWG did weather effects so well...along with so many other things.

    How am I going to /slap Darth Vader in any other IP and get force choked unconcious?

  • TerranahTerranah Stockton, CAMember Posts: 3,574 Uncommon
    The IP was part of it.  I love Star Wars.  I think a game with SWG's mechanics could still be successful without the IP, but there are other factors to consider such as the setting or graphical style.
  • DreskestDreskest El Paso, TXMember Posts: 69

    Well. t really depends on the mechanics to be used in said game :  game using pre-cu mechanics would have a better chance at success in my opinion, while it would be extremely hard for a game with post-cu mechanics to succeed, especially without the SW IP.

     

    In any case, I'd be all over a game like that, if only for the superb crafting system. Have heard people saying The Repopulation is using a lot of elements from the original SWG, so I can only hope the final product is similar.

     

    Still sad SWG is gone. It was my primary reason to keep my SOE Station Access.

Sign In or Register to comment.