It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
So looking at the last review on mmorpg.com seems like the outdated review will stay up forever, here is a quote from the second paragraph of the review:
Here at MMORPG.com, we are aware that games are always patching and game updates are pending pretty much forever. However, until those changes are live on the servers, we cannot anticipate how they will affect the gameplay or community, and therefore those rumors and announcements do not affect the score card detailed below. We feel we’ve waited more than long enough to give FFXIV a fair shake. Check back with us later this year for an update after those changes are live.
Um... yeah this update never came, I am posting after this review was released http://www.rpgfan.com/reviews/Final_Fantasy_XIV/index5.html which is putting the game in a decent light.
Mmorpg never delivered on this update on the changes the said they would give, could it have been because the game is getting better, and they did not want to post a half way positive review?