Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Fuzzy Avatars Solved! Please re-upload your avatar if it was fuzzy!

Combat in GW2 for Melee HAS TO CHANGE!!

135

Comments

  • ScriptZScriptZ Sunnyside, UTPosts: 70Member

    Originally posted by Opapanax

    I can see where people would feel like melee is at a disadvantage with range. I also from what I've been getting from my play time as thief that melee DPS does out shine the range in the actual speed you can put out the dps.

    When in PVE at least I can really feel a difference between taking a mob down with melee when compared to range. It is alot more dangerous since you have to watch for mob abilities also but you do alot more meltface up close instead of ranging them for a bit.

    /shrug

    Sure there's some overall balancing to do still though.

    I basically just use melee when i'm fighting trash mobs unless i get way out numbered then I pull out my bow and use it to take there numbers down some then I pull out my daggers again to finish the stragglers off. Also I use bow on storyline bosses because they hit so dang hard and usually get lucky with hits sometimes if I try and kite with melee, so I just use bow and kite to make it a little easier on myself.

  • Sector13Sector13 New Providence, PAPosts: 687Member
    I think the combat over all needs changed. GW2 combat is too much of a tab targetting game for mobs in it to deal the damage they do. Even with a dodge mechanic, it's too easy to get hit especially by ranged enemies and litterally makes being melee pointless. The damage needs toned down a lot for the combat that this game uses. I understand what they were going for but it's pretty badly implemented. I was playing PSO2 more over the weekend then GW2 cause of the poor combat. PSO2 is a real action combat game that is challenging. GW2 is a tab targetting game that is more like an arcade game to suck in your quarters with unfair combat mechanics that down you more then it should. 
  • spaceportspaceport CatalunyaPosts: 405Member

    Wait.... so melee classes in this game have animation lock while ranged classes can bunny hop and jump while using skills with no problem? isn't this going to be a kite fest?

     

    Or do they also have animation lock?

     

     

    I have to say... it's kinda ironic to see so many people defending this when 2 weeks they where all bashing Tera for having animation lock (like all action games do).

    image
    "Esport with tournaments is for hardcore pvp'rs that want to be competitive. Openworld PVP with ganking and griefing is for casuals that just wants their pvp mixed with pve from time to time."
    otacu

  • StoneRosesStoneRoses Seattle, WAPosts: 1,055Member Uncommon
    Seriously you started another thread about how bad you are at playing GW2! The game doesn;t need to change, you need to learn2play!

    image

  • heartlessheartless Brooklyn, NYPosts: 4,993Member

    First of all, there are very few abilities that actually root you in place. The rest of them, even the ones that are channeled and have a casting time can be cast while moving.

    Melee is a bit harder to master than ranged but it's not impossible. The thing that a lot of people don't understand, yet is that this game is made for you to switch weapons on the fly and it's not a good idea to be just melee or just ranged for most classes.

    There are some really hard encounters though, like that shaman that wiped 30+ people, but most other encounters are not too hard at all. Keep in mind that this is beta and ANet is buisy gathering various metrics and things will change for release.

    Edit: also, a lot of people seem to fail to grasp this concept but in GW2 you have to MOVE.

    image

  • JoeyMMOJoeyMMO SomewherePosts: 1,326Member

    Originally posted by Atlan99

    Originally posted by Fadedbomb

    Originally posted by Atlan99

    It's like this in every mmo I've played.

    Basically it comes down to this, you brought a knive to a gun fight."

    Fortunately in GW2 every class has range attacks. So use them and use melee when it is appropriate.

    DAOC didn't have this issue :)! (Thane vs Eldritch anyone?)

    Everquest didn't have this issue :)! (Monk vs Wizard anyone?)

    ShadowBane somewhat had this issue, but it depended on your build :D!

     

    I'm worried that people are experiencing the wrong games :|!

    Really? In larger scale PvP range owns. It's like that in very game. I just played DAOC and it was the same thing. 

    From what I could stomach playing of DAOC, GW2 WvWvW trumps it in every way.

     That's a pretty strong statement from someone who used to praise SWTOR and hate on GW2. I guess Anet must be doing something right. DAOC trumped in every way by GW2 WvWvW, that's saying something.

    imageimage
  • AmegashieAmegashie naPosts: 282Member Uncommon
    I've been doing a lot better on a Guardian than on an Engineer, and I mean A LOT. Just gotta play it smart and not charge into huge crowds of enemies on your own. The auras and support skills are fantastic, the damage is quite decent ( I'm using Mace+Board and Greatsword ) and the overall package seems much more well rounded than the Engineer, whose kits I found to be somewhat underwhelming to be honest.
  • ariboersmaariboersma Yankton, SDPosts: 1,802Member

    I think melee is fine for attacking, but yea the casted abilities probably should be spread out, not all on one weapon. I have only played the ranger and I have NEVER liked melee ranger until now.. but thats more because greatsword does way more damage than either bow.. my weapons are nearly the same lvl btw. So for me I liked the melee set up except for one thing.. damage from PVE. There needs to be less normal damage so that you dont die fighting normal attacks.. yes of course still dodge the big stuff that needs to stay, perhaps make them more noticable.. cast bars on the mobs would be nice so that its easier to see when there are alot of bodies.

    I thought I should add that ranger greatsword only has a 3 string 1 ability and a bleed for attacks, otherwise its a charge/leap, counterattack and a stun from behind or daze.

     

    oye MMORPG is dying.. its taken me 3 min+ to fix this typo!

    image

  • ariboersmaariboersma Yankton, SDPosts: 1,802Member

    Originally posted by spaceport

    Wait.... so melee classes in this game have animation lock while ranged classes can bunny hop and jump while using skills with no problem? isn't this going to be a kite fest?

     

    Or do they also have animation lock?

     

     

    I have to say... it's kinda ironic to see so many people defending this when 2 weeks they where all bashing Tera for having animation lock (like all action games do).

    there is no animation lock I think the OP is speaking of a stutter when you first use an ability.. or like how if your using an ability that is channeled you cant change abilities.. you can still move while channeling it though.

    image

  • AldersAlders Jack Burton'sPosts: 1,857Member Uncommon

    You can melee and kill stuff twice as fast but run the risk of getting 1 or 2-shot.

    You can range and take twice as long to kill stuff but take little to no damage.

    This is for PVE of course as i destroy people with melee in PVP.  You just need to pick your battles and not run into packs of people.

    Seems fine to me but i haven't seen some of the large boss encounters later on so my opinion may change.

  • MMOExposedMMOExposed lalal land, DCPosts: 6,255Member Uncommon

    how in the world do you use Ring of Warding with queued melee attack in WvW if everybody is moving?

    come on

    image

  • MMOExposedMMOExposed lalal land, DCPosts: 6,255Member Uncommon

    I just tried this again with Hammer.

    Mighty Blow can be interrupted by Movement. WTF!!!

    image

  • BeansnBreadBeansnBread PshPosts: 5,498Member Uncommon

    Originally posted by MMOExposed

    I just tried this again with Hammer.

    Mighty Blow can be interrupted by Movement. WTF!!!

    Doesn't sound like a good PvP weapon choice.

  • Freedom4u2Freedom4u2 Quebec, QCPosts: 27Member Uncommon

    I personally had no real problems with my warrior on that point. I could bash stuff in melee range and dodge carefully, or go range with a rifle and blast stuff from afar without any real danger (but it took twice as long).

    I know, however, that the Guardian has a pretty different approach, but I did not experience it with the Thief. You should also note that Guardians are support and not pure melee -- they can also attack from range (both of them).

    There is absolutely NO reasons to say melee is broken. It is not; would you jump into an army of armed centaurs with one sword and some mail armor and expect to survive? It's just a matter of logic.

    image

  • Eir_SEir_S Argyle, NYPosts: 4,623Member
    This is one time I might agree with this guy.  Ranged players have no obvious disadvantages when pitted against melee, and then melee is forced to stop, thereby losing critical catch-up time, leaving them even more exposed to ranger arrows or the niggling little spells from scholar classes.  I like melee, it's fun but it does need to be changed if they want better balance.  This isn't even getting into the PvE, where mobs mow you down if you're melee and you're almost forced to use a gun or a bow if you want to live (I'm referring to big mobs where it's impossible to see all the telegraph animations in order to use your dodge carefully).
  • TorvalTorval Oregon CountryPosts: 7,187Member Uncommon

    Originally posted by Eir_S

    This is one time I might agree with this guy.  Ranged players have no obvious disadvantages when pitted against melee, and then melee is forced to stop, thereby losing critical catch-up time, leaving them even more exposed to ranger arrows or the niggling little spells from scholar classes.  I like melee, it's fun but it does need to be changed if they want better balance.  This isn't even getting into the PvE, where mobs mow you down if you're melee and you're almost forced to use a gun or a bow if you want to live (I'm referring to big mobs where it's impossible to see all the telegraph animations in order to use your dodge carefully).

    They will balance, nerf, buff, and adjust as necessary.  I don't know if you're a GW1 player, but if ANet can and does any one thing in a game it's constant tweaking of skills and balance to make sure fotm doesn't steamroll, at least not for long.  In GW1 they do weekly balance tweaks to skills and classes for both pvp and pve.  If anything the balance adjustments can get annoying because you might just be getting into a build, skill, and combat rhythm only to have that change next week.  I can't imagine it being much different for GW2.

  • ZolbZolb mansfieldPosts: 53Member Uncommon

    Originally posted by PieRad

    I don't know about guardian, but I played a warrior, and it was one of the most fun experiences I've had in a long time.

    GW2... I'll give you that! :P

     

    I could move while casting, except for killshot i believe (F1 skill with rifle)... I don't remember if dual axes had any cast time, but I was constantly moving, the only problem i had was skills going off even though I weren't in range of my target (that's a good thing!) just because I didn't know the class all that well yet.

    Using a skill out of range of your target will set that ability on cooldown.

    But I quickly figured out that your abilities' hotkey will turn white if you're in range of your oponent with a particular skill, so I did fairly well with the warrior in the end, that was in instanced PvP mind you, never went to the mist.

     

    Might be a different story in the mist, with 50 players around you, don't know.

     

    if Guardian can't move while casting, maybe his skills are more powerful to make up for the loss of mobility? Or maybe a bug, no idea?...



    my experiance is very similar to yours, apart from i only played WvWvW on my warrior, im not usually into PvP play in MMO's usually leave it for games like TF2 etc but i had a blast to day, played about 8 hours of WvWvW if not longer, as for people running away, just use the utility skill "throw bolas" imobilizers the target for 4 sec's.

     

  • CrunkJuice2CrunkJuice2 asdasd, INPosts: 568Member

    "They will balance, nerf, buff, and adjust as necessary."

    they can balance,but theres a difference between balancing pvp right.and balancing it wrong

     

  • MMOExposedMMOExposed lalal land, DCPosts: 6,255Member Uncommon

    That Circle of Warding is nearly impossible to trap players because the cast time. usually players are on edge and can walk over it.

     

    if I move, it gets interrupted and CD goes off!!!

     

    I thought this game suppose to allow moving while casting as a major feature. guess they left out melee attacks on that list...

    image

  • CrunkJuice2CrunkJuice2 asdasd, INPosts: 568Member

    ya it doesnt really make sense that a melee cant cast and move anyway

     

    thats like,taking out the entire reason why ive loved melee dps over ranged and casters in other mmorpgs.oh well,mesmer seemed like a fun class

     

     

  • k-damagek-damage ParisPosts: 738Member
    I didn't see my Thief or my Warrior being forced to stand still with cast skills, they were perfectly able to move while casting ... wtf are you talking about ?

    ***** Before hitting that reply button, please READ the WHOLE thread you're about to post in *****

  • heartlessheartless Brooklyn, NYPosts: 4,993Member

    Originally posted by k-damage

    I didn't see my Thief or my Warrior being forced to stand still with cast skills, they were perfectly able to move while casting ... wtf are you talking about ?



    The guardian has certain skills that root him in place. It depends on the weapons though. Not all weapons work all of the time and certain weapon combos are situational. Apparently OP found such a combo and is whining that it does not work 100% of the time.

    image

  • AIMonsterAIMonster Apopka, FLPosts: 2,059Member

    Do people not realize melee does as much as 2X damage as ranged weapons?  I use Sword + Warhorn on my Ranger most of the time and only switch to bow when I need to kite for a while and avoid damage.  Melee is actually more powerful in Conquest most of the time (though timing your weapon switches between both is the best way to ensure the most damage) due to it's high damage.  Use of dodge rolls and evasion/tanky abilities is important in melee range.

    Melee cannot be more powerful than it is now.  If they buff it, it will be over the top.

    image

    Raptr link because it's the cool new trend:
    image

  • TheocritusTheocritus Gary, INPosts: 3,734Member Uncommon

    Originally posted by MMOExposed

    Originally posted by sk8chalif

    so this thread is all about u complaining about the guardian right? if u want to play a melee go warrior



    Both Warriors and Guardians suffer from this issue. To pretent like this isnt the case, wont solve anything here.

    Melee
     

    This game is built around Ranged combat. and Meleers suffer from it.

     

           Kinda like how Warhammer turned out in the later levels

  • Rhianni32Rhianni32 Denver, COPosts: 222Member

    I'll add in my vote into the overwhelming "melee is fine learn 2 play" category.

    PLayed guardian and it was fine. ran around with mace shield and sword shield most of the time in WvW.

Sign In or Register to comment.