It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
If the devs over at blizzard listened to everything I have said in their "Official forums" I would be surprised.
Anet can definitely afford an Official Forum but why would they need one when they have fansites that have forums? The devs at Anet go to guildwars2guru to give answers and look at questions. Whats the point of a developer making a forum just to call it official? Developers are people you know. They arent confined to only accessing Guild Wars 2 website.
You sir OP, thought very little when making this thread because if you knew anything about Anet you would know that they look at fansites and forums on those fansites.
-I am here to perform logic
Originally posted by blondeh maybe they cant deliver on their promise like every other mmo dev and wont be able to handle the onslaught of QQ's
Well the issue there is to find the signal amongst all of the noise. In my experience, actual useful criticism is about 5% of all the QQ posts that end up on official forums. Really most of the posts are just total opinionated bullshit.
And for those that keep repeating on where would they report bugs and such, there are already support forums. That is what they are used for.
Originally posted by Dream_Chaser The only problem with GW2G is that the moderators are kind of knee-jerk and quickfire when it comes to edits, deletes, and locking.
Honestly I've always thought that was one of the main reasons Anet didn't have an 'official' forum in the GW1 days. The fan sites could, and often were, be as draconian as they wished and Anet's hands were clean. Send Gaile Gray around to drop a tidbit every once in a while and watch the fan sites do your work for you. If an official forum was ever half as draconian as GWGuru could be there'd be hell to pay. But since it was a fan site Anet could shrug and say "Isn't us!".
Never really understood why people were mostly (the subject did come up with fair frequency) fine with this, but not surprised Anet is going down the same path again.
They are a game developer not a babystting service.
Grim Dawn, the next great action rpg!
well moderation is a fine line, someone will complain either way
Dyslexia Warning: Grammar Trolls be gone
Given the sheer craziness on these forums i'd personally rather they continue with what they are doing right now since there seems to be a "my game's better then yours" forum wars going on in these forums which would explain the reaction you got OP from saying what you said in the title of this post. That they can't afford one. (even my ten year old nephew knows that's not true)
So, I'd rather have an in game means of sending them feedback about their game in a civilized manner and cut out all the nonsense that happens in these forums because as you can see from my signature it happens all too often, some fanboy of another game is going to go out of their way to say something negative and completely untrue of GW2 just to make it seem worse then it is. (this is opposed of course to the hours of footage, the documentation and the time the rest of us put into finding out the truth about these titles to make an informed decision and let others know about what we've found)
Oh and then there are the games that say they have open forums but censor like crazy just to keep people in their own game from pointing out how bad a game REALLY is instead of fixing the issues with a game and saying they are sorry for messing up, charging people for something that shouldn't have been released yet, and making the game as best a player experience they can possibly make their game.
Originally posted by shane242 okay, forums.. Fan sites tend to have a much better community, unfortunately there isn't normally a need for them as the official forum is the place to be.
Oh really.. i preffer to talk with some one who own the game instead of all random peoples.
Secondly.. fan sites got ads with viruses, fanatic mods, AND nothing tell me that devs will ever read my post.
Originally posted by catplay Originally posted by shane242 okay, forums.. Fan sites tend to have a much better community, unfortunately there isn't normally a need for them as the official forum is the place to be.
what makes you think they would read your posts on an official forum either? Unless it's on a support forum, your chances are slim to none.
Send them an email, you don't have to throw forum tantrums with 100 other trolls to get your points across.
Originally posted by DJJazzy Originally posted by catplay Oh really.. i preffer to talk with some one who own the game instead of all random peoples. Secondly.. fan sites got ads with viruses, fanatic mods, AND nothing tell me that devs will ever read my post.
Funny enough did Strain spend a lot of times on fan forums when he was the head of ANET.
I have no clue about if Mike or Erik do the same though. But the uestion is how much actual devs ever read on a official forum, posts by them are rare in most cases, 9or none existing..
Originally posted by Dream_ChaserThe only problem with GW2G is that the moderators are kind of knee-jerk and quickfire when it comes to edits, deletes, and locking. They're only dealing with a TINY community right now. I feel that needs to be stressed. Guild Wars 2 is likely going ot be thousands of times bigger than GW1, and they could potentially have millions of people pouring in there when the game goes live.Now, consider the shortfalls of this... unstable approach to moderation. Let's say that someone reporting a bug has their thread deleted because a mod misread their post, and every time they try to repost, it gets deleted. And then the mod gets paranoid (and I have seen this happen on GW2G) and starts deleting all threads relating to that bug. They do have paranoid trips over there. I've seen it first hand, it's ugly.Again, imagine this with a couple of million people posting. They'd lose control. Someone is bound to flip out in a really bad way, because, again, they have some control freaks there, people who get paranoid, people who shouldn't be moderating in the first place, people who don't have the right mindset for it.When this blows up, and I can guarantee you that it will, it's going to be a PR disaster for ArenaNet.That is why you need an official forum.Consider this bit of easy to understand wisdom: A GW2G moderator isn't under contract, and most of them are volunteers and not being paid. Not only that, but these volunteer moderators are likely completely anonymous even to the GW2G staff. So they have no accountability and they require no real sense of responsibility. Nothing bad can happen to them if they flip a shit, other than being banned from GW2G. They can just get another name and keep going. But the damage to ArenaNet's reputation because of this would be irreparable.GW2G is okay as a site, but their moderators just aren't prepared for the massive influx, and their moderation style does not fit a body of people that large. If ArenaNet doesn't get their own forum and leave the responsibility with GW2G, then... well, this is all going to go horribly, terribly wrong.
I want to emphasize all of this and add to it. Every time I look at GW2G (which is less and less now), I see several posts that are locked for one of these reasons:
"There isn't enough to discuss on this topic.""It looks like everyone has already stated their opinions.""This can be discussed in whatever mega thread where a different discussion is already taking place."
No thread locked in these or similar ways violate any rules, and yet all of the mods lock threads like this constantly. I would call that being a rogue moderator. They are disregarding rules and locking threads on their own whims. They are not "keeping the peace". They're treating the community like their own personal gardens and pruning away whatever threads they happen to not like the look of.
Originally posted by Dream_ChaserOriginally posted by Shroom_Mage Can't edit on mobile but want to add that the vast majority if GW2 players will never know guru exists. That alone makes it an abysmal excuse for an official forum, and I could still come up with several other reasons why guru is abysmal.
Well, they could tell everyone about it. They could link it as a "Recommended Forum" as they did with Guild Wars.
And that's where I see it all falling apart...
The thousands of voices complaining about how ArenaNet told them to go to a forum where they can't even report bugs without a moderator leaping on them...
Yeah, this is going to end well.
Yeah... recommending GW2G would be the absolute worst move they could make in this situation.
"Be who you are and say what you feel because those who mind don't matter and those who matter don't mind." -Dr. Seuss
When you don't have an official forum, you give way for a lot of other sites to foster a community. These communities then hold their own tournaments and events. This is still possible with an official forum, but it won't be as elaborate.
That has been their last "official" stance on official forums. MMO's with official forums generally have small communities outside their official game site.
Ever wonder why MMORPG.com has so many Guild Wars 2 fans? Because there is practically an unofficial official community here. Same place happens at all the other fan sites.
All this probably wouldn't happen if everyone just stuck to the official forums.
Now then, with that, if you follow other big games, you see that the developers who participate in the forums are usually the PR people. Not so with Guild Wars 2. Even on unnoficial forums, their systems designers and lead designers are constantly dropping in to clarify things.
That is much more official than PR marketing.
Originally posted by shane242 okay, forums.. Class forum - every single class is underpowered, every other class is OP. No matter what class forum you go to, its the same. Useful feedback that is. Server forum - Flame, flame and more flame. Support forum - Same questions repeatedly, though this is needed imo as issues getting the game running will loose users (non that the payment model is really effected right away) PvE - I want better loot blah blah, X is to hard we can't down him but we are so uber pro PvP - I lost, the game is broken and unbalanced, the one where you have to get the flag.. now what is it called again.. hmm? at the end of the day the feedback is pretty unless to the devs, its a poor community, and a ongoing cost that's a waste. Fan sites tend to have a much better community, unfortunately there isn't normally a need for them as the official forum is the place to be.
Mmmmm... so not true. Sure, each of those forums contain those types of posts but they also contain-
Spec'ing properly is a gateway drug.12 Million People have been meter spammed in heroics.
Originally posted by Muntz Originally posted by Puremallace Originally posted by Saxx0n SWTOR has a forum and look how it turned out.......
The devs were held accountable for bad decisions. God forbid. Nice communist system you believe in there.
Wouldn't a single centralized forum controlled by the very entity that is invested the most in it be more communist?
Forums provide a very small mechanism for feedback. I doubt highly if the only feedback they had was forum QQ that any serious changes would have happened.
quick pro-tip from someone who has seen mallace's posts elsewhere. Ignore him, he's been banned because all they attempt to do is flame and troll anything GW 2-related. There is an occasional bit of insight rarely, but overall their "opinion" is about as invalid as one can be. They also don't know what Communism is, Comrade.
As for the whole Official/Fan forum thing, what works works. The ArenaNet team is active on most every GW site I'm a member of, and while an "Official" forum would serve to unify the community, people would still end up using fansites regardless. I have nothing against the concept of an official forum, but generally speaking the amount of "troll" posts increases exponentially when everyone posts in one forum and said forum is an official part of the game. It can also wring out more drama as well, which tends to swell and bloat things as well, specially when server-specific forums are around.
Guild Wars has a support forum, which is actually one of the few "required" things I like to see in an MMO.
Guild Wars Guru seems to work well enough as a focal point, since a vast majority of in-game community events is announced through there. And yes, while an official forum would make it probably easier to spread news of those events around, it again opens it up to more trolling and drama. I've already seen some occasional "trolling" done by guilds or individuals during these community events, and I'd hate to give them an easier time to do so by opening up forums for them to infest.
Originally posted by catplay So ANET can't afford a forum? Why? I mean.. every serious company can, but not them? I guess they do not like peoples to come and said what they do not like? What do you think?
I recall in Guild Wars 1 that there was a decision not to have a company message forum, but to support top Fan run forums with some developer posts etc. instead.
Company decision, can't remember their reasoning at the time.
2 reasons why the launch of GW2 will be great:
1) You get to play the game
2) The constant string of non-issue threads (like this one) cease to exist.
Forum whiners getting their way have negatively effected games from DAOC to SWTOR; I for one could care less if there isn't a "NERF SORCS NOW; I lOST AND AM BUTT HURT" forum.
The OP still hasn't answered the question posed to him/her.....who said Anet can't AFFORD an official forum? Note the word "AFFORD." Where did you get THAT idea?
President of The Marvelously Meowhead Fan Club
If anyone else had did this, we would never hear end of it. Anet does it, and it's "ok".
In War - Victory.In Peace - Vigilance.In Death - Sacrifice.
Who says they can't afford it, OP? There's really no point in following this logic to a conclusion with no factual basis for the discussion in the first place. Also, what is a "serious" company?
Happy Friday, regardless!
Noone isn't a word; It's "no one". On a side note, you can guess where the word "none" came from.------------------------------Their, There, and They're are not interchangeable.
Originally posted by Roin If anyone else had did this, we would never hear end of it. Anet does it, and it's "ok".
ArenaNet hasn't "done" a damn thing yet. The game isn't released. So why don't we wait and SEE what they're going to do? What a novel idea. This game has so much assumption both good and bad that it's ridiculous. I really think it makes more sense to wait and find out the TRUTH of the matter before wiggin' out.
I don't see the value in a company forum. It's a very vocal minority trying to convince the devs they are the majority. Then you end up with a game catering to a minority, thus pissing off the majority that never even visit a forum. If they really want feed back , submit polls to customers at login (optional of course) with the ability to submit an opinion (they would need to limit wording to 500/1000 words or be hit by walls of text). This way much of the emo drama can be avoided, as it really doesn't add any value.
I will always aprove this decision, from any MMO developer.
Oficial non-technical related forums are for whiners and trolls only.
Originally posted by Rivalen Originally posted by Roin If anyone else had did this, we would never hear end of it. Anet does it, and it's "ok".
Ain't it the truth? One only has to look at the WoW forums and WoW's history of DEvolution into what it is today, to SEE the reason for NOT having "official" forums (other than tech support, of course).
Still....we have no idea for certain what Anet will ultimately do, so this whole conversation is kind of silly. From what they've SAID...I tend to think they won't have them, but again....we don't know for sure right now.