Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Suspicious of all the bad reviews...

123468

Comments

  • botrytisbotrytis Member RarePosts: 3,363

    If you like ESO - great.

     

    That said, it is NOT the 2nd coming of anything. It is a console game that they have a port for the PC with. The MOBS look terrible, what were they thinking? They spent so much time with the environment and it's looks but nothing looks 3D it is very unidimensional. Also, they spent tons of money on voice acting, John Cleese, Michael Gambon, etc. and nothing on the combat. The toons for the players look awful too and the way they look running, riding, etc is laughable.

     

    If they want me to play this game, they need to make it B2P as this game has as much depth as a mud puddle.


  • BadSpockBadSpock Member UncommonPosts: 7,979

    Could be that *GASP* many of the reviewers are long-time game players, including the single player TES titles, and long-time MMO gamers, and they actually don't like what they see.

    Or, the first 10-15 levels are just as boring and uninspired as the previews make them seem to be, which despite how much "better" the rest of the game MIGHT be, according to NDA breakers mind you, is a horrible, horrible design decision by Zenimax.

     

  • simon155simon155 Member UncommonPosts: 53

    That's your opinion, as you've said.

     

    As I've said, I disagree, and have a great deal of first hand evidence that many others disagree too. The game rocks ;o)

    All it comes down to now is long term appeal and how much it grows.

  • SeelinnikoiSeelinnikoi Member RarePosts: 1,360

    Only had to play the Beta weekend to know the crap that game is. No review necessary.

    You should try it too.

    PS: Roll an archer archetype and shoot arrows while near enemies, watch the arrows go where your aim is not. Magically bending to lock to the enemies and hit them...

    Love that "deep" combat.

    If you are a Star Wars fan, why not try the Star Wars The Old Republic?
    New players can get a welcome package and old/returning players can also get a welcome back package and 7 days free subscription time! Just click here to use my referral invitation
  • UhwopUhwop Member UncommonPosts: 1,791
    Originally posted by Seelinnikoi

    Only had to play the Beta weekend to know the crap that game is. No review necessary.

    You should try it too.

    PS: Roll an archer archetype and shoot arrows while near enemies, watch the arrows go where your aim is not. Magically bending to lock to the enemies and hit them...

    Love that "deep" combat.

    But, but, you can dodge!!!

  • simon155simon155 Member UncommonPosts: 53
    Originally posted by BadSpock

    Could be that *GASP* many of the reviewers are long-time game players, including the single player TES titles, and long-time MMO gamers, and they actually don't like what they see.

    Or, the first 10-15 levels are just as boring and uninspired as the previews make them seem to be, which despite how much "better" the rest of the game MIGHT be, according to NDA breakers mind you, is a horrible, horrible design decision by Zenimax.

     

    That's kinda inaccurate too. As someone who has played through the single player titles myself, but also played MMOs such as WoW and many others, I know the difference between Single Player games and MMOs. This certainly is an elder scrolls game, but it's also an MMO. I'd say exactly as it says on the box.

    I love it. Lots of other people love it. In fact the vast majority I've spoken to love it. It just seems those who don't love it are over represented on these threads.

     

    That said I guess it's all good - It's like the Simon Cowell effect.  The more talked about it is, the more people will check it out themselves. It was the same when I first heard of WoW - I saw it mentioned in a negative way on a thread. Looked into it and loved it. Stuck with it for a good few years until they destroyed it catering too heavily for the elitists. Those days are long gone though lol.

  • nytkinnytkin Member CommonPosts: 14

    You're on to something here, and I totally agree with you.

    I've been playing MMOs, every MMO I can get my gamer-addict hands on, since Everquest, Acheron's Call, and Ultima Online.

    I can honestly say that I was thoroughly pleased with and immersed into ESO from the first hour of play on Friday night, during  my first foray into the Beta test.

    I agree that ESO much more engaging and pleasing to play than AoC, Rift, DDO, Lotro, and many other MMOs that have come out since the Everquest days.

    I was thoroughly impressed with every aspect of the game, and will definitely play it when it releases. I look forward to playing in all the factions, and plan to level several characters up to try out the various classes and races.

    /lute

    Devil bunny needs a ham, and he's pretty sure knocking you off a building will get him one.

  • Soki123Soki123 Member RarePosts: 2,558
    Nothing to be suspicious about, it s a lousy game.
  • Mackaveli44Mackaveli44 Member RarePosts: 708
    All I can say is play the game till about 10 and than it seems to come into its own.  At first your on a starter island so you can expect much from it till past that.  Around 10, is around when it comes into its own and takes off.  Ignore the reviews and form your own... And, all I can say about Cyrodiil(the pvp grounds) is that is the word Epic doesnt do it justice.  It is far beyond epic, amazing, fantastic, insanely fun....
  • funyahnsfunyahns Member Posts: 315
    Originally posted by WikileaksEU

    Bad reviewers have played too much World of Warcraft. They are also comparing ESO with Skyrim, which is fucking stupid, as Skyrim is purely single player and ESO is an mmorpg. Big difference in both software and hardware.

     

    Edit: Gamers today are spoiled and need a good slap in the face. Such a hard slap to the face they fly away across the room and into the wall behind them and leave a mark there.

     So you disagree with people who don't like the game and think physical assault is what is needed to put them in place?  Most of the negativity I have heard has nothing to do with WoW and everything to do with dullness in  game.  If they didn't want a comparison to Skyrim they shouldn't have used the IP.

  • Gobstopper3DGobstopper3D Member RarePosts: 965

    For one, don't let this site or any other decide for you what to like or dislike.  The few on forums who cry the loudest are also the minority and it will always be this way.  The success or failure of a game isn't decided on a forum, it's decided by the majority of the folks who don't bother posting on here or any other forum.

    If your wondering if you should spend your money on it?  Wait for a trial or ask a friend whom you know in person and has actually played the game at length after release.  These are just opinions on here, just like mine and you know what they say about opinions.

    I'm not an IT Specialist, Game Developer, or Clairvoyant in real life, but like others on here, I play one on the internet.

  • BcudaBcuda Member UncommonPosts: 164
    Originally posted by Dulu

    Been on the MMO scene for a very long time, and I've seen companies like MMORPG.com and other review sites suck the **** of games that have been terrible, just because they have big names.

     

    Age of Conan, Warhammer and Guild Wars 2 being the most notable. Anyone who was an MMO veteran when these games were releasing probably remembers thinking these games would be the next WoW, or the next Jesus Christ, etc. That's what the review companies were spouting.

     

    And then you actually got to play the games... and yeah, we know the history.

     

    My point is, why is it all of a sudden a game like ESO, which I thoroughly enjoy and think is so much better than anything that has released in years, is getting such terrible reviews, while games which almost no one enjoyed - received such AWESOME reviews?

     

    What's going on? Did Zenimax not pay someone? Is this an organized plot by a competitor? I hate to be the conspiracy theory guy, but I don't understand. Or, is this just some sort of meme which has spread across the internet like wildfire, or doge? "ESO sucks, not worth $15, armor painted on, blah blah blah" (Anyone else notice the reviews all use the exact same terminology? I had never heard anyone say "armor painted on" before ESO, yet I've heard it in EVERY-SINGLE-REVIEW!)

     

    I'm a skeptic, and I think some BS is going on..

    Nope! If the painted on armor was the real problem. This would be an easy fix... But its not.. But I am curious to find out the AWESOME review. Because there has not been a good game in a long long time... I think Bill Murphy did a fine review. But always goes a little to soft on the painful stuff..

  • GravargGravarg Member UncommonPosts: 3,424
    The problem with reviews are that they're not your point of view.  All you can tell from a review is if the game works or not.  Whether or not you'll like it is totally different.  There have been many games that reviewers did not like, but I loved.  The original FFXIV was probably the biggest difference.  Everyone said that the game was no fun and blah blah blah, but I enjoyed my time in the game.  The heists were boring to me, but getting in a group of friends to go farm "NM"'s brought back so many good feelings from old games, I could sit there for hours just doing that.
  • simon155simon155 Member UncommonPosts: 53
    Originally posted by Seelinnikoi

    Only had to play the Beta weekend to know the crap that game is. No review necessary.

    You should try it too.

    PS: Roll an archer archetype and shoot arrows while near enemies, watch the arrows go where your aim is not. Magically bending to lock to the enemies and hit them...

    Love that "deep" combat.

    I love it :)

     

    haha you'd make a funny game designer. I can just imagine the response to your new game:

     

    "Don't roll an archer. You shoot your arrows forward and people just move to the side. Seriously it's rubbish. You can't hit anything. Why bother with archers.. omg.. wtf... etc. etc... lol"

  • jdnewelljdnewell Member UncommonPosts: 2,237
    Originally posted by baphamet

     


    Originally posted by rodingo
    Sure it could be some conspiracy that people are being paid to badmouth the game.  However, I think the more realistic approach is that they are just saying what they feel about the game.

     

    or maybe they are scared of the backlash they will get from their readers by saying anything positive about the game?

    writers will say whatever they need to say to get people to read their articles or subscribe to their youtube channels.

    i mean, if i took these "reviews" to heart, i would think that ESO was one of the worst mmo's ever created and i know that isn't true so something isn't right here.

    Exactly.

    Whatever garners the most hits, sells the most magazines, ect.

    And essentially what they wrote about was a 1st impression. Most didnt even get to level 10, play any PvP or experience much of anything beyond an hour or two of game play.

    add to the fact that damn near everyone who applied for beta got in to try it, even gave out free keys to some sites, and people can form their own opinions.

    The game may suck, or may be the game your looking for. Form your own opinion. If your hesitant just wait to buy it and get some feedback from people who play for more than an hour and predict doom.

  • coventryhagdogcoventryhagdog Member Posts: 85
    Originally posted by Dulu
     

    My point is, why is it all of a sudden a game like ESO, which I thoroughly enjoy and think is so much better than anything that has released in years, is getting such terrible reviews, while games which almost no one enjoyed - received such AWESOME reviews?

     

    What's going on? Did Zenimax not pay someone? Is this an organized plot by a competitor? I hate to be the conspiracy theory guy, but I don't understand. Or, is this just some sort of meme which has spread across the internet like wildfire, or doge? "ESO sucks, not worth $15, armor painted on, blah blah blah" (Anyone else notice the reviews all use the exact same terminology? I had never heard anyone say "armor painted on" before ESO, yet I've heard it in EVERY-SINGLE-REVIEW!)

     

    I'm a skeptic, and I think some BS is going on..

     

    The reason why they are no longer shilling is because of FTC regulations.

    Websites all over the USA are getting fined by the FTC for a lack of online disclosure, which means that you have to state that you are getting paid to give positive feedback, or make positive posts.

    When shills come on here and post for their parent companies, they put mmorpg.com in a very precarious position.

    That is the reason why.

     

    A company just got fined over 300k USD for making false reviews.

     

  • maendrosmaendros Member UncommonPosts: 26

    I dont trust reviews positive or negative. 

    Btw i was negative towards the game and i didnt like it till lvl5. When the game opens it becomes much better even as a themepark. Cyrondiil is fantastic and smooth much better and immersive than gw2 WvWvW.

    I dont get it . Zenimax should have scrapped this linear introduced tutorial areas at the start.

  • time007time007 Member UncommonPosts: 1,062

    How about this, lets just wait until the game comes out + 1-2 months.  So the launch won't mean crap, what will be important is who drops off after hitting the level cap AND have to decide to pony up 15 bucks for the 2nd month subscription after the first free months.  Tons of people drop off then (myself included most of the time).  Then further so after the 2nd month going into the 3rd when those guys who subbed for 1 months regret what they've done as they've been at the level cap for 1+ month without jack to do. 

     

    So I think the 3rd month and those guys still playing can tell us how dead it is and how much the game sucks.  I'm guessing we will all ding level cap in 2-4 weeks.  Anyone think you will have to play longer than 2-3 weeks to hit the level cap?

    IMPORTANT:  Please keep all replies to my posts about GAMING.  Please no negative or backhanded comments directed at me personally.  If you are going to post a reply that includes how you feel about me, please don't bother replying & just ignore my post instead.  I'm on this forum to talk about GAMING.  Thank you.
  • neroistneroist Member Posts: 24

    I believe that most people have been conditioned of how to play and what to expect in MMOs. Most people want to rush to the "endgame" max out their toon, and be drip feed loot.

    I believe ESO is a game where you are supposed to immerse yourself into the world and that is where the game shines. A MMORPG where you can Role Play! Become a person in a loving cafted fantasy world.  Not play the game a loot simulator.

  • UhwopUhwop Member UncommonPosts: 1,791

    I'm suspicious of threads created by forum users who's account is created after a beta weekend that saw the media pretty much blast the game.

    Nothing suspicious here guys. 

  • SemibruceleeSemibrucelee Member Posts: 52

    Maybe most people had high expectations. The same people also probably didn't go really far in the game.

    My first reaction, especially to the combat, was also meh; a bit clunky, you can't really dodge (that double tap is for show), you don't really aim at mobs (auto-lock). But that game grows on you, and although animations could be better, everything else is well done. Now I'm seriously contemplating buying it.

  • WikileaksEUWikileaksEU Member UncommonPosts: 108
    Originally posted by amber-r

    I would assume that a company the size of bethesda and Zenimax know how to influence public opinion.

     

    Just have to wait for them to start, it's really not hard to change opinion of a game.  All they have to do is put out advertising, pay all the mmo and game websites for large amounts of advertising so they instantly like your game and pay the youtube celebrities to cover the game.

     

    It's pretty industry standard but for some reason they aren't doing it, maybe they are making the mistake of spending the money on the game instead of the payoffs.  Anyone that saw the reviews games like Guild wars 2 and ffxiv2 got and that played them will see how this industry works. 

     

     

    Guild Wars 2 is one of the best mmorpg made, so you're wrong in that statement.

  • simon155simon155 Member UncommonPosts: 53

    You know if you get paranoia that badly you can see your doctor for medication right?

    People usually create accounts to reply to threads they are interested in, assuming they don't already have one. I bet lots of people are creating accounts about ESO at the moment, on the basis EVERYONE seems to be talking about it lol.

    In some regards, the negative chats brilliant. If anything, it's the Simon Cowell effect. It ensures it's widely known. The more sites it pops up on the better. Keep it up lol.

     

    In the meantime the majority of us, who hear about a game and look into before forming our own opinions will keep being prompted to go check it out. Good work. Don't stop, and keep those potential guild mates flooding in ;)

  • simon155simon155 Member UncommonPosts: 53

    As an experiment lets see how credible this forum is as a reflection of typical attitudes.

     

    Vote in the poll. A month or so after release, we'll judge how well replies from here reflect the market reaction, and if this forum is at all credible for estimating public response ;)

     

     

  • botrytisbotrytis Member RarePosts: 3,363
    Originally posted by WikileaksEU
    Originally posted by funyahns
    Originally posted by WikileaksEU

    Bad reviewers have played too much World of Warcraft. They are also comparing ESO with Skyrim, which is fucking stupid, as Skyrim is purely single player and ESO is an mmorpg. Big difference in both software and hardware.

     

    Edit: Gamers today are spoiled and need a good slap in the face. Such a hard slap to the face they fly away across the room and into the wall behind them and leave a mark there.

     So you disagree with people who don't like the game and think physical assault is what is needed to put them in place?  Most of the negativity I have heard has nothing to do with WoW and everything to do with dullness in  game.  If they didn't want a comparison to Skyrim they shouldn't have used the IP.

    Spoiled human beings need to get hurt physically to free themselves from their ignorant mind. A hard punch or slap to the face usually solves the problem.

     

    ESO isn't dull. It's very immersive and get many things right. I do agree animations and some things need work though.ESO isn't the worst mmorpg ever made, it's one of the best. I've played the beta for more than 20 hours. It's 2 months till release and most stuff will get fixed in those two months, believe me. Reviewers totally bashing it and saying it's shit are bad reviewers and thought it would be like a single player Skyrim, or they are WoW players and are too used to floating numbers and gear that show big numbers.

    Immersive - not really. with the way the characters move and the NPC's so static - there is no immersion at all. Also the MOBS move but they are so predictable. The many mobs share the same model - imps, bats and harpys all look the same. Even thought the environment is pretty, it doesn't look 3D (like barrels etc.). You can tell it was drawn on a sheet of paper.

     

    It is NOT one of the best MMO's I have played and I wanted to really like is, since I have played many of the ES single player games.

     

    The reviewers who saying the game is bad, well, it is their opinion. You don't like it, don't read them. The truth does hurt when you are a blind FAN BOI..


Sign In or Register to comment.