It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!
My brother in law just got his new comp and asked me the same question this weekend - he was looking to get into a new game and wanted to see what I thought.
I told him to try EVE, because even though it wasn't for me, I thought it was a solid game.
I told him not to try SWTOR, because I was so turned off by its original implementation and its shoddy F2P practices.
I was curious as to what everyone else thought too, because outside of WildStar and TESO I haven't been following PC/MMO gaming development as much recently.
Are there any "hidden gems" that people might have overlooked but are really fun? Is there anything out there that is supposed to be great but really isn't?