Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Not quite so Clear as Mudd?: No tokens....but commendations?

Lore84Lore84 NorthamptonMember Posts: 69

08/02/2013 #2 – RvR isn’t the end game, it’s the only game!">Foundational Principle #2 – RvR isn’t the end game, it’s the only game!

"You will get rewards for killing other players, other players’ helpers and some stuff in the world but it won’t be gear and we will also not offer tokens. Tokens are for subways and some pinball and arcade games, not for this game. I was and remain a fan of that type of system for a different game(s) but not for this game."

 

18/02/2013 As to Gold Sellers

"4) Gold will not be the only currency system we will have. Players will earn special commendations for their work from their sovereign that will reward them for special services to their realm whether they are crafters, builders or RvR players or all of the above."

- Mark Jacobs

 

Seems like a contradiction to me, is that not tokens?

Can we get some clarification on this? Im really not sure about this since if its a return of a commendations system ala WAR, can we expect that sort of almost forced gear grind and the issues that go along with it? This is probably the most negative thing i've heard about the systems in the game so far if im being honest.

 

Ex-DAOC, Excalibur

Comments

  • kryllenkryllen Home, MAMember Posts: 26
    Good catch - it sounds like either token farming or faction farming...same thing really.

    We The Few - Gaming Nomads: Rants, Ravings, Reviews and Randomness
    Kryllen / Cup - Alb/Palo
    Seires - Gaheris and Mid/Kay
    Phoxx/Phsxx - Mid/Ywain

  • Lore84Lore84 NorthamptonMember Posts: 69
    Originally posted by kryllen
    Good catch - it sounds like either token farming or faction farming...same thing really.

    I so hope not.

    Ex-DAOC, Excalibur

  • MarkJacobsMarkJacobs CEO City State Entertainment Fairfax, VAMember Posts: 552 Uncommon

    Originally posted by Lore84

    08/02/2013 #2 – RvR isn’t the end game, it’s the only game!">Foundational Principle #2 – RvR isn’t the end game, it’s the only game! "You will get rewards for killing other players, other players’ helpers and some stuff in the world but it won’t be gear and we will also not offer tokens. Tokens are for subways and some pinball and arcade games, not for this game. I was and remain a fan of that type of system for a different game(s) but not for this game."   18/02/2013 As to Gold Sellers "4) Gold will not be the only currency system we will have. Players will earn special commendations for their work from their sovereign that will reward them for special services to their realm whether they are crafters, builders or RvR players or all of the above." - Mark Jacobs   Seems like a contradiction to me, is that not tokens? Can we get some clarification on this? Im really not sure about this since if its a return of a commendations system ala WAR, can we expect that sort of almost forced gear grind and the issues that go along with it? This is probably the most negative thing i've heard about the systems in the game so far if im being honest.  

    Originally posted by kryllen
    Good catch - it sounds like either token farming or faction farming...same thing really.

    Neither actually. :) Think of commendations that could come in the form of special medals/titles/achievements.

    To me, tokens are things that you farm that then can be used to buy other things. Commendations are things you are given that are not leveled up (100 tokens = this item, 200 tokens = that item) that might be nothing more than an achievement (Slayer of Arthurians) or additional grants of land (which can only be given out by the ruler), etc. 

    What you will receive will not be able to be used to buy/trade for non-player crafted items/weapons/etc.

    Also, we haven't decided whether they totally make sense or not yet. I want to keep my options open if we feel that the currency system is being borked by the gold sellers.

    Think about something like making a heroic stance one night and you receive a special commendation from the king because you held the keep that night. It might not have any physical value but it would be listed as something you achieved in your character sheet.

    Does this make sense?

    Mark Jacobs
    CEO, City State Entertainment

  • kryllenkryllen Home, MAMember Posts: 26
    As an achievement yes - as a currency item no.

    We The Few - Gaming Nomads: Rants, Ravings, Reviews and Randomness
    Kryllen / Cup - Alb/Palo
    Seires - Gaheris and Mid/Kay
    Phoxx/Phsxx - Mid/Ywain

  • Lore84Lore84 NorthamptonMember Posts: 69
    Phew, it does..thats fine. I just had flashbacks of WAR there for a second. *shudder*

    Ex-DAOC, Excalibur

  • MarkJacobsMarkJacobs CEO City State Entertainment Fairfax, VAMember Posts: 552 Uncommon
    Originally posted by kryllen
    As an achievement yes - as a currency item no.

    And I'm hoping that's where it stays. As I said to the guys this morning when we talked about it, I just want to make sure we have a backup plan if I'm wrong about gold sellers. I want our players to be able to generate enough gold/items to make a viable economy. If the gold farmers find a way to exploit it, I could add a secondary currency that would be bound to the player and only transfered via a sale of an item. While this is still exploitable (like any system), it would make it harder for the farmers/sellers to exchange gold. Not impossible but just a little harder.

    Sorry for the misunderstanding.

    Mark Jacobs
    CEO, City State Entertainment

  • GaladournGaladourn AthensMember Posts: 1,077 Uncommon
    Originally posted by MarkJacobs
     

    or additional grants of land (which can only be given out by the ruler)

    this would be an excellent way to give clans/guilds the ability to build strongholds close to the contested areas.

    Also, it's so medieval it's...perfect from all aspects :) 

  • skyexileskyexile MelbourneMember Posts: 692 Common

    Mark needs to use only WoW terms so everybody understands, I call it simplified MMO dialect.

    SKYeXile
    TRF - GM - GW2, PS2, WAR, AION, Rift, WoW, WOT....etc...
    Future Crew - High Council. Planetside 1 & 2.

  • kryllenkryllen Home, MAMember Posts: 26
    Originally posted by MarkJacobs
    Originally posted by kryllen
    As an achievement yes - as a currency item no.

    And I'm hoping that's where it stays. As I said to the guys this morning when we talked about it, I just want to make sure we have a backup plan if I'm wrong about gold sellers. I want our players to be able to generate enough gold/items to make a viable economy. If the gold farmers find a way to exploit it, I could add a secondary currency that would be bound to the player and only transfered via a sale of an item. While this is still exploitable (like any system), it would make it harder for the farmers/sellers to exchange gold. Not impossible but just a little harder.

    Sorry for the misunderstanding.

    Well I hope the same then. Really want your game to succeed so hopefully more detailed news comes out soon. As it is, it's about 50/50 good/bad for me so far...especially the no PVE part.

    We The Few - Gaming Nomads: Rants, Ravings, Reviews and Randomness
    Kryllen / Cup - Alb/Palo
    Seires - Gaheris and Mid/Kay
    Phoxx/Phsxx - Mid/Ywain

  • Lore84Lore84 NorthamptonMember Posts: 69
    Sky, that's pretty snide. You have to admit that wasn't at all clear.

    Ex-DAOC, Excalibur

  • MarkJacobsMarkJacobs CEO City State Entertainment Fairfax, VAMember Posts: 552 Uncommon

    Originally posted by kryllen
    As an achievement yes - as a currency item no.

    Cool.

    Originally posted by Lore84
    Phew, it does..thats fine. I just had flashbacks of WAR there for a second. *shudder*

    Don't worry, I have learned a *few* lessons over the years. :)

    Originally posted by Galadourn

    Originally posted by MarkJacobs
     

    or additional grants of land (which can only be given out by the ruler)

    this would be an excellent way to give clans/guilds the ability to build strongholds close to the contested areas.

    Also, it's so medieval it's...perfect from all aspects :) 

    That's the plan. :)

    Mark Jacobs
    CEO, City State Entertainment

  • RaagnarzRaagnarz North Las Vegas, NVMember Posts: 274 Uncommon
    I like the idea that it would only, for the moment anyway, be tied to titles or things like that. That being said, I like that you already have a backup plan in place based on gold farmers. Its kind of hard for botters to excel at pvp while at the same time meeting their hourly quoatas. So do what you gotta do man lol.
  • MarkJacobsMarkJacobs CEO City State Entertainment Fairfax, VAMember Posts: 552 Uncommon
    Originally posted by Raagnarz
    I like the idea that it would only,m for the moment anyway, be tied to titles or things like that. That being said, I like that you already have a backup plan in place based on gold farmers. Its kind of hard for botters to excel at pvp while at the same time meeting their hourly quoatas. So do what you gotta do man lol.

    Exactly. The key is making it easy for real players to have fun, make money, build and make stuff but make it harder for the commericial farmers to make money. Not easy but doable.

    Mark Jacobs
    CEO, City State Entertainment

  • HokibukisaHokibukisa Midland, GAMember Posts: 185

    Think of them like realm points and bounty points.

    Realm points = XP - you keep it

    BP = commendations - you don't keep it.. well you can horde it

    image

  • skyexileskyexile MelbourneMember Posts: 692 Common


    Originally posted by Lore84
    Sky, that's pretty snide. You have to admit that wasn't at all clear.

    Oh yea it wasnt totally clear. but my while my reply was alitlte sarcastic in bagging wow...i was kinda been serious.

    SKYeXile
    TRF - GM - GW2, PS2, WAR, AION, Rift, WoW, WOT....etc...
    Future Crew - High Council. Planetside 1 & 2.

Sign In or Register to comment.